Operation Cast Lead and the Goldstone Report, Revisited Five Years Later

...The final verdict on Goldstone would thus seem to consist in two possibilities. One, if he was really of the opinion that the Hamas regime were the innocent victims of Israel’s “closure regime,” and that Israel was really the harsh, oppressive, apartheid nation whose marauding hordes were unleashed to terrorize the good people of Gaza on a whim, then the motives of his involvement in this inquiry and his authorship of the Report were consistent with the highest moral standards of human rights advocacy. Two, if he was not, then, at the very least, he knowingly allowed himself to be used by those he knew to be unfriendly to Israel for the sinister purpose of darkening and defaming the Jewish state with the most heinous crimes that any nation can stand accused: the deliberate commission of war crimes against a defenseless people.

Robert Werdine..
Times of Israel..
02 January '14..

Excellent, a must read! Y.

On the night of November 4, 2008, Israeli troops crossed into the Gaza Strip near the town of Kissufim and targeted a tunnel that Hamas terrorists were planning to use to capture Israeli soldiers positioned on the border fence some 250 meters away from the border and directly adjacent to an IDF border outpost, not unlike the one they used to seize soldier Gilad Shalit a few years back. Intelligence had established that Hamas operatives had been specifically trained for a planned abduction, and that they planned to activate the tunnel in a few days.

Hamas gunmen were waiting there for them; they had anticipated the possible discovery of the tunnel by the IDF and had thus had the entrances to both ends manned and heavily booby trapped. In the firefight that followed, six Israeli soldiers were injured, two of them seriously. Two Hamas gunman were killed, and several injured, and they then let fly with a volley of mortars at Israel. An Israeli air strike then killed five more Hamas fighters. In response, Hamas launched 35 rockets into southern Israel, one reaching the city of Ashkelon.

A six month lull/cease-fire had been established in June 2008 between Israel and Hamas that was brokered by Egypt, and the IDF spokesperson made clear that the operation was not an attempt to abrogate the cease fire:

“This was a pinpoint operation intended to prevent an immediate threat,” the Israeli military said in a statement. “There is no intention to disrupt the cease-fire, rather the purpose of the operation was to remove an immediate and dangerous threat posted by the Hamas terror organization.”

The tunnel skirmish of November 4, 2008 was then met by Hamas in the launching of some 193 rockets and mortars in November, and some 290 between December 1 and December 24, every one of them a war crime.

The Hamas regime, upping the ante, now demanded the following terms for a renewal of the lull/cease-fire, which lapsed on December 18: a complete opening of all border crossings, an opening of the Rafah border with Egypt, and a ban on all IDF activity in Gaza. Hamas was thus now demanding a removal of all the restrictive measures and “IDF activity” that the terrorist actions they had previously committed, and were currently committing, had made absolutely necessary.

On December 24 Hamas launched “Operation Oil Stain” to the accompaniment of a 60 rocket and mortar volley. On December 25 Israeli Prime Minister Olmert said: “I am telling them now, it may be the last minute. I’m telling them stop it. We are stronger.” This was met with an attack of 5 rocket and 14 mortar attacks, and the next day there were 12 more. All efforts to constrain or contain the attacks being ineffective, on December 27 Israel commenced Operation Cast Lead, a three-week sustained military strike on Hamas’ terror infrastructure and rocket launching sites in an effort to thwart future attacks.

But such spurious claims are belied by the facts.

Read more: Five Years Later: Operation Cast Lead and the Goldstone Report, Revisited | Robert Werdine | Ops & Blogs | The Times of Israel http://blogs.timesofisrael.com/five-years-later-operation-cast-lead-and-the-goldstone-report-revisited/#ixzz2pK8ZDkD6
Follow us: @timesofisrael on Twitter | timesofisrael on Facebook

Noam Chomsky, Andrew Sullivan, Norman Finkelstein, Richard Falk, and others have all charged Israel with responsibility for deliberately breaking the ceasefire that led to the Cast Lead operation, have pointed to Hamas’ willingness to renew the ceasefire, and have cast doubt on whether the Israeli response was thus really legitimate self-defense. The Goldstone Report, too, makes clear its view of Israel’s responsibility for the escalation of rocket attacks in the weeks following the tunnel incident, attributing it to Israel’s “preventive measures,” the closing of border crossings, and the harsh privations inflicted by Israel’s “closure regime” of Gaza, whose horrors are elaborately inventoried for the benefit of the reader, while Hamas’ rocket and mortar attacks, along with their attempt to kidnap another Israeli soldier, are barely mentioned in passing.

(Continue)

Robert Werdine lives in Michigan City, Indiana, USA. He studied at Indiana University, Purdue University, and Christ Church College at Oxford and is self-employed. He is currently pursuing advanced degrees in education and in Middle Eastern Studies.

Updates throughout the day at http://calevbenyefuneh.blogspot.com. If you enjoy "Love of the Land", please be a subscriber. Just put your email address in the "Subscribe" box on the upper right-hand corner of the page.Twitter updates at LoveoftheLand as well as our Love of the Land page at Facebook which has additional pieces of interest besides that which is posted on the blog. Check-it out! 
.