Saturday, March 26, 2016

Where human rights violations must have a "made in Israel" sticker on them. - by Khaled Abu Toameh

...If the putative champions of the Palestinians in the West continue to disregard the trampling of Palestinian human rights by the PA and Hamas, there may not be any Palestinians left to champion.

Khaled Abu Toameh..
Gatestone Institute..
25 March '16..

These are the days when everything is backwards. The "pro-Palestinian" activists on university campuses throughout the Western world have gotten into the spirit: Palestinian students and academics in the West Bank and Gaza Strip endure daily harassment by the Palestinian Authority (PA) and Hamas, because all that gets the activists going are "Israeli abuses."

Apparently, today, to be "pro-Palestinian" one has to be "anti-Israel."

For the self-appointed advocates of the Palestinians at Western university campuses, the Palestinian issue is nothing but a vehicle for spewing hatred toward Israel. In good, backwards form, Israel is castigated, and the PA and Hamas are free to abuse their own people.

It seems that in the view of the anti-Israel folks, the Palestinians should not even hope for human rights under the Palestinian regimes.

So while the anti-Israel activists are busy protesting against Israel on Western campuses, Palestinian students and professors are left to be persecuted by their own governments.

Instead of campaigning for reform and democracy in the West Bank and Gaza, these activists spend precious energy trying to take down Israel. The Palestinian students and academics are left to their own devices.

Palestinians living under the Palestinian Authority and Hamas suffer an abysmal level of freedom of expression -- and always have. This is the grim reality that the international community and protesting students prefer to ignore. For them, human rights violations must have a "made in Israel" sticker on them.

Here is a suggestion: Let us redefine "pro-Palestinian." Instead of bashing Israel, the real pro-Palestinians will reveal themselves by demanding democracy for those they champion. True pro-Palestinian activists will scream for public freedoms for the Palestinians under the PA and Hamas regimes, which have always smashed dissent with an iron fist.

In the past few days, Palestinians on campuses in the West Bank and the Gaza Strip have once again been reminded that they remain as far as ever from achieving a state that would look any different from the other Arab dictatorships in the region. The campus incidents, which have hardly caught the attention of the international media and anti-Israel activists in the West, also expose the media double standard about human rights violations in the territories.

Friday, March 25, 2016

Haaretz, Tears and Hypocrisy - by Prof. Asher Maoz

If only Haaretz columnist Rogel Alpher empathized with Israeli victims of terrorism as much as he did with EU foreign policy chief Federica Mogherini after the Brussels attacks. But like the U.N. Human Rights Council, Haaretz only feels Palestinian pain.

Prof. Asher Maoz..
Israel Hayom..
25 March '16..

Like many others, I watched as tears flooded the eyes of European Union foreign policy chief Federica Mogherini during a press conference in Amman. Like most of us, I empathized with her reaction to the wave of terrorist attacks in Brussels, the EU capital. In an opinion piece in Haaretz, journalist Rogel Alpher empathized, too, with "the rare moment of humanity" and "the most natural, healthy emotional reaction."

It was clear to me, however, that Alpher doesn't dispense compliments for nothing, and wanted to cash in. Indeed, after his compliments for this humane, gentle woman, came the attack on a "young macho [guy] at the Channel 10 foreign news desk," who Alpher said "expressed crude Israeli contempt toward [Mogherini]."

And the guardian of morality's anger wasn't reserved for the young macho guy; he had plenty for Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, who in his speech to the American Israel Public Affairs Committee shortly after the Brussels attacks had the audacity to argue that terrorism in Belgium and Israel "was the same terrorism."

I never cease to wonder at the Christian morality dripping from the pages of Haaretz.

Salt in the wounds

I'm sure that Uri Misgav also identifies with Mogherini's tears and is mourning the Brussels victims of terrorism. I got the impression that that human emotion did not cause him any pain over the murders of Naftali Frenkel, Gil-ad Shaer, and Eyal Yifrach, who were picked up at a hitchhiking post and murdered by Hamas terrorists in the summer of 2014.

And not only did Misgav not mourn them, he even criticized their families, who asked people to pray for their sons' safety. His cynicism is so far gone that as soon as their bodies were found and before we had managed to take in the evil, he rushed to note that "the prayers didn't help."

Gideon Levy is also undoubtedly sorry for the Brussels victims. That same Levy stuck a knife through the hearts of the three boys' mothers, who went to Geneva to plead with the U.N. Human Rights Council to help save their sons.

Levy chided the miserable mothers: "You need a certain amount of gall to demand that the world take an interest in the fate of three abducted Israelis, and a certain amount of audacity to be disappointed when it remains silent."

With brutal cynicism, he rubbed salt into their wounds, adding that "the world has no reason to take an interest in the fate of Naftali Frenkel, Eyal Yifrach, and Gil-ad Shaer. ... It has no reason to be moved by the chilling words of Rachel Frenkel, who said that her Naftali was a good boy who liked to play the guitar and basketball."

Levy the moralist even went so far as to mock anyone who referred to the two 16-year-olds and the 19-year-old as boys. "Why not babies?!" he asked cruelly.

Zero condemnation of terrorism

But why do we have to look as far as Misgav or Levy? In a piece titled "An apology to my murderers" published not long ago, Alpher leaves a will that should be handed over "if a terrorist runs me over or stabs me."

"If I'm murdered in a terrorist attacks, I ask that my murderers be told in my name, if they are still alive, that I apologize. That I'm making up with them after my death. And if my murderers die, then I'm apologizing to them now, ahead of time," Alpher wrote.

It's hard to know if this will happen before or after he leaves the country, as he promised/threatened to do a year and a half ago. Alpher concluded that promise with the sweeping statement: "What goes for Tel Aviv goes for the communities on the Gaza border."

Nevertheless, despite Alpher's self-righteousness, it was impossible not to identify with the pain of the EU foreign minister. But along with the pain, she and her entire European community should be reminded that the evening of the terrorist attacks in Brussels, the son of peace activist Richard Lakin, who was murdered in a terrorist attack in Armon Hanatziv in Jerusalem appeared before the U.N. Human Rights Council.

Surprise? U.S. and EU-Trained Palestinian Official Blames West for Brussels Terror Attack

...When a spokesman for the PA security forces essentially blames the West for terrorism in Brussels, and his charge is reflected in the authority’s daily paper, shouldn’t donors to the PA to reconsider whether their aid money is being well spent?

Sean Durns..
CAMERA Snapshots..
24 March '16..

A spokesman for the Palestinian Authority’s (PA) security sorces has blamed the United States and Europe for the March 22, 2016 Brussels, Belgium terrorist attack for which the Islamic State in Iraq and Syria (ISIS) claimed responsibility.

On the day of the attacks that murdered 31 people, PA security forces spokesman Adnan Al-Damiri wrote on his Facebook page:

“Those who prepare the poison will taste it themselves, and today Europe is having a taste of what it prepared with its own hands.”

Al-Damiri’s remarks were reported by Palestinian Media Watch (PMW), a non-profit organization that monitors Arab media in the West Bank (Judea and Samaria), the Gaza Strip and eastern Jerusalem.

After claiming to offer a brief perfunctory condemnation of “terrorist acts everywhere in the world,” al-Damiri’s Facebook post makes clear that he blames the West for Islamist terror. He claims that “we Arabs are the ones who have been most severely burned by the fire of terror, which has been created and exported by the US and Europe since the Arab Jihad fighters in Afghanistan, and before that by exporting the Jewish terror to Palestine, supporting it and justifying it. Today, Europe is being burnt by its [the terror’s] fire in its airports and squares.”

Al-Damiri conveniently overlooked that Arab terrorists fighting under the banner of Islam existed long before the United States and its allies, including Arab countries such as Saudi Arabia, supported mujahiddeen [holy warriors] in the fight to repel the Soviet Union from Afghanistan in the 1980s. As CAMERA has previously noted (“Au Contraire, Prof. Picketty: Income Inequality Does Not Cause Middle East Terrorism,” Dec. 9, 2015), Islamist terrorism predates the period of Western involvement in the region. In addition, terrorist groups comprised of Arabs living in and near British Mandatory Palestine attacked Jews long before the recreation of Israel as a modern state in 1948.

What We Could Learn from Israel - by Vijeta Uniyal

...Recent terrorist attacks in Brussels, Mumbai, Paris, Istanbul and Ankara are simply what Israel has been living with for decades -- and India, France, Belgium and Turkey do not have "settlements." The conflict is not about "settlements". It is about one group of people trying imposing its will, culture, religion and way of life on another group. With Israel, the "settlements" are only the pretext. If you look at any map of "Palestine," it has the exact outlines of Israel. It is beyond our scope, as Indians, to heal the pathologies of the Muslim world. We can only limit the damage by defending our home and securing our national borders. Until that day comes, we would all do well to stand with Israel.

Vijeta Uniyal..
Gatestone Institute..
24 March '16..

For most Indians, it is hard not to feel a deep sense of historic gratitude towards Israel and the Jewish people. The State of Israel came to our military aid in just about every war India fought as an independent nation since 1947. Our elected leaders, in their vanity, polished their statesmanlike credentials denouncing Israel at every possible international gathering, even as they kept on turning to the Jewish State for help in times of dire need, whether civilian or military. From Golda Meir to Ariel Sharon, Israel never turned down any request.

Getting nothing in return, the tiny and beleaguered nation paid a price for its support for India. At times, adversely affecting its relations with China or annoying its most vital ally, the United States, by extending support to a "socialist" country at the height of the Cold War.

If there ever was a true sign of goodwill extended from one nation to another, Israel had shown it toward India and so many other nations, from Zaire to Haiti and elsewhere.

Despite this, it took India more than four decades just to treat Israel as an equal partner on the world stage -- when India established full diplomatic relations with Israel in January 1991.

India, however, had one redeeming quality. Although our political leaders hitched their wagon to the Soviet Union and the Pan-Arab nationalism in the early days of the Cold War, the Hindus of India, who constitute an 80% majority of the country's population, have been steadfast and consistent in their support for the State of Israel and the Jewish people. An international survey conducted by Israel's Ministry of Foreign Affairs in 2009 found Indians having the most favorable opinion of Israel, even ahead of U.S. respondents by a small margin. In August 2014, at the height of Gaza conflict, the city of Calcutta staged a 20,000-strong rally in support of the Jewish State, making it probably the largest pro-Israel rally that Asia ever witnessed.

Finally, with the election of Prime Minister Narendra Modi in May 2014, the India's official policies have begun to reflect the desires and aspirations of the majority Hindu population of the nation.

To become a successful nation, we realize that we have to emulate the Jewish quest for spiritual and worldly learning. We need a nation of empowered men and women, free and fearless to develop social, technological, entrepreneurial and humanitarian creativity, even while under constant attack.

Remembering Jewish Victims in Istanbul - by Stephen Flatow

...I only hope that the victims of last week’s attack on Istanbul will not be so quickly forgotten, as Harold Rosenthal and the other victims of the 1976 massacre seem to have been.

Harold W. Rosenthal, who was killed in a
1976 terrorist attack in Istanbul.
Photo: Youtube/Screenshot.
Stephen M. Flatow..
Algemeiner.com..
23 March '16..

JNS.org – The Turkish and Israeli authorities are still investigating the motives and plans of the Islamist terrorist who murdered three Israelis, two of them Israeli-Americans, in Istanbul last week. I can’t help but be reminded of another terrorist attack in Istanbul, 40 years ago this summer, in which Israelis and Americans were murdered.

On Aug. 11, 1976, terrorists from the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine (the PFLP) opened fire at the El Al Terminal in the Istanbul airport. They murdered four people and wounded more than 30 others, including two American women. One of the dead was 29-year-old Harold W. Rosenthal.

Now, it shouldn’t matter where Rosenthal lived, or what his job was, or even that he was an American citizen.

But the way the world works is that if somebody from a particular city is killed, people in that city naturally are more interested than if the victims were people from other cities. And employees of a particular company naturally take a greater interest in the fate of their fellow-employees than the employees of other companies. And American citizens who are harmed by terrorists abroad are entitled to certain rights and protections from the American government, which they would not receive if they were not Americans.

So let it be noted that Rosenthal was from Philadelphia; he had served on the staff of then-US Rep. Hugh Carey (D-NY) and US Sen. Walter Mondale (D-Minn.). At the time of his murder, he was a senior aide to US Senator Jacob Javits (R-NY).

And here’s why that matters.

Thursday, March 24, 2016

Dying for Allah - by Brig.-Gen. (res.) Yossi Kuperwasser

....President Barack Obama exemplified this mindset in his 2009 Cairo address and in his address in Jerusalem in 2013 when he said there was no real difference between his daughters and the Palestinian youths he had met in Ramallah or the Egyptian youngsters he had encountered in Cairo....Really, Mr. President? Do your daughters identify on Facebook with the worldview of radical Islam, which calls on one to seek “death for Allah”? Palestinian youth indeed wear jeans and do not look religious. Yet almost every Palestinian child you ask will tell you he wants to be a shahid [martyr], and many believe that by attempting to stab a Jew-Zionist to death they increase their chances to attain that honor. This is a direct result of the education they receive.

Brig.-Gen. (res.) Yossi Kuperwasser..
Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs..
23 March '16..

The sensitivity to criticism of the Islamic fundamentalist attitude on the “death for Allah” concept, which has been fully adopted by the Palestinian cultural code, is a further instance of our difficulty in understanding a different culture, which leads us to project our own values onto the other in a mirror-perfect image.

President Barack Obama exemplified this mindset in his 2009 Cairo address and in his address in Jerusalem in 2013 when he said there was no real difference between his daughters and the Palestinian youths he had met in Ramallah or the Egyptian youngsters he had encountered in Cairo. Like his daughters, they wanted to get an education, worship God in their way, raise a family, and make a good living, even if there were political or religious differences between them.

Really, Mr. President? Do your daughters identify on Facebook with the worldview of radical Islam, which calls on one to seek “death for Allah”? Palestinian youth indeed wear jeans and do not look religious. Yet almost every Palestinian child you ask will tell you he wants to be a shahid [martyr], and many believe that by attempting to stab a Jew-Zionist to death they increase their chances to attain that honor. This is a direct result of the education they receive.

The Tenet of Dying for Allah

According to radical Islam and the distorted way in which its tenets have been harnessed to the Palestinian national struggle, “death for Allah” is an important value. The main message of the Koran is that life’s purpose is to help one realize that the universe was created by Allah; one can then bear witness that there is no other God than Allah and Muhammad is his last emissary. Those who do so in this life will merit being in heaven in the next world, which is the truly important world, until the resurrection of the dead. Those who devote themselves to spreading this message, while fighting the enemies of Allah and Satan’s endeavor to convince people that there is no God and what matters is worldly happiness, will win further favors in heaven including the renowned virgins, especially if, during this struggle, one sacrifices one’s life and becomes a shahid.

Two verses from the Koran, often used in proclamations by the Palestinian organizations that glorify terrorists recently killed while carrying out attacks, explain an aspiration that to us seems to contradict human nature: to commit murder while risking one’s own death. One of these, verse 169 of the House of Imran surah, states: “Do not think of those who die for Allah as dead, for they are alive and receive their sustenance from their Lord.” The distortion involved in the use of this verse concerns the assertion that it descended (according to Islam, the verses of the Koran descended from heaven and were given to Muhammad by the Angel Gabriel) in the context of a regular war, the Battle of Uhud, which Muhammad waged against members of his tribe, Quraysh, along with his followers, some of whom had left Mecca with him while others were from Medina. When these followers feared taking part in the battle, there was a need to boost their spirits. There is, of course, no similarity between that war and inhuman attacks on innocent people that are justified in this fashion.

AIPAC’s Post-Trump Hangover - by Jonathan Tobin

...The job of a bipartisan lobby in age of hyper-partisanship is not easy. But it must be done. Pinkus should save her tears and her apologies. Once the Trump hangover wears off friends of Israel are going to have their work cut out for them in trying to maintain the alliance between these two great democracies no matter who wins in November. That’s going to mean working with lots of people that a lot of don’t like. AIPAC activists and their critics need to get used to it. It’s called democracy.

Jonathan S. Tobin..
Commentary Magazine..
23 March '16..

Donald Trump surprised a lot of people on Monday night when he read a fairly standard pro-Israel speech at the AIPAC conference. But while his performance got mixed reviews as even those, like me, who were willing to give him some credit for repudiating his claim of “neutrality” and saying a lot of sensible things about the conflict with the Palestinians and the Iran nuclear deal, understood that the gap between scripted Donald Trump and the unscripted version that has said very different things is too great to be ignored. In the aftermath of the speech, Trump has gone on to say more outrageous things about different subjects (the latest being a thuggish threat aimed at Ted Cruz’s wife) but the pro-Israel lobby seems to have been shaken by the criticism the organization received for applauding the candidate’s address.

The best evidence of this came the morning after when Lillian Pinkus, the new president of AIPAC took the stage at the conference and tearfully apologized for some of the things Trump said. The GOP frontrunner had taken some harsh shots at President Obama about his policies toward Iran and Israel. He cheered the notion that it was the president’s final year in office and then added, in a deviation from his script, that Obama was, “maybe the worst thing to happen to Israel.” Obviously, that last line was a piece of classic Trump hyperbole. If compared to Yasir Arafat, Hamas and Mahmoud Abbas, Obama doesn’t seem quite so bad even to his critics.

But Pinkus’s apology wasn’t so much about what Trump said but the fact that the vast majority of the 18,000 AIPAC conference attendees applauded him. The expectation prior to the speech was that a great many of those at the event would walk out as the candidate spoke or that he might be booed or heckled. That was a not unreasonable expectation since Trump is despised by a great many Jewish conservatives as well as liberals. But while a few staged a symbolic walkout or stayed away — something that was barely noticed in a packed arena — the AIPAC crowd gave him a respectful hearing as they did the other candidates.

More than that, when Trump told them things they wanted to hear about support for Israel, the Iran deal or even Obama, they didn’t sit on their hands. They laughed at his jokes and applauded. Trump’s appeal as a performer is a lot greater than his critics, including me, have been willing to acknowledge. And for some, including apparently some of AIPAC’s leaders, that applause was an unforgivable sin for which the organization must make amends.

Let’s specify that by naming Obama in the way that he did, Trump used what we might term unparliamentary language in a setting where even partisans understand that bipartisanship is the order of the day. But, to be fair, despite Pinkus’ tearful apology about “ad hominem attacks” that were “levied against the president of the United States from our stage,” this wasn’t the first time a sitting president was criticized at an AIPAC conference. Moreover, by Trump’s admittedly debased standards, merely saying Obama was the “worst thing” or saying “yay,” about the prospect of him leaving office barely registered even as a mild insult. But Pinkus’s apology for a guest speaker that spoke only for himself and not AIPAC was, as the Washington Post noted, unprecedented.

Why did she do it?

UN Council for Terrorist Rights. Beyond bias. It’s obsessive. It’s insanity. - by Yair Lapid

...Alon Bakal was shot to death in Tel Aviv. He was 26. A volunteer in a humanitarian organization. He was what they call a ‘human rights activist.’. And how does the UN Human Rights Council respond when a human rights activist was murdered? They support the murderer. The treatment of Israel by the Council is far beyond bias. It’s obsessive. It’s insanity.

MK Yair Lapid..
Times of Israel..
21 March '16..

We stand here, Jews and non-Jews. From Israel and from across Europe, to protest the fact that instead of doing what they’re supposed to do, the United Nations Human Rights Council is encouraging murder, encouraging terror, encouraging injustice.

And we are not willing to remain silent anymore.

That is not a Council for Human Rights. Instead, it has become a Council for Terrorist Rights.

In the past decade the Council has passed 55 resolutions regarding human rights violations throughout the world: the entire globe. With all of its endless conflicts. In the same decade, in the same ten years, the Council has passed sixty two resolutions against Israel. Seven resolutions more about Israel than about the entire rest of the world.

During that decade, Israel was constantly under attack from terrorists who set out to kill civilians: women, children, the elderly.

Our enemies mock the core concept of what it is to be human, while at the same time we are trying to protect a democratic state while adhering to the highest standards of international law.

We face fundamentalist Islamic terror organizations who want to murder Jews just because they are Jews.

We face Iran and its terror subcontractors, which has declared again and again that its goal is the total destruction of Israel.

And we face sixty two resolutions by an organisation which deceives the world by calling itself a Human Rights Council.

Four hundred thousand murdered in Syria, tens of thousands murdered in Iraq, in Libya, in Afghanistan — and the Council condemns Israel.

Women are raped in Rwanda, Sudan and all across the Middle East — and the Council condemns Israel.

People are beheaded and women are forced into slavery in Iraq — the Council condemns Israel.

Three million people are displaced in Syria — the Council condemns Israel.

The Israeli-Palestinian conflict is only ranked forty-ninth in the number of casualties in conflicts across the world. But there is only one country – only one – which the rules of Human Rights Council dictate has a special agenda item.

Let me introduce you to Agenda item 7, which states that every time the Council is in session it has to discuss – even if nothing happened, even if no evidence has been presented — the human rights situation in Israel.

Why?

Obama doctrine, Global chaos and its implications for Israel and the Jewish people

...Despite the fact that anti-Semitism, assimilation and intermarriage will continue to erode the vitality of Diaspora Jewish communities, increasing numbers of committed Jews will make aliya, either by choice or to enable their children to grow up in a society in which they wear their Jewishness as a badge of honor. Despite the trials and tribulations of the Jewish people, we can rejoice in the knowledge that our future remains assured with Israel. Over the past half century, the Jewish state has made extraordinary progress, is self-sufficient and is proud of our achievements as the startup nation.


Isi Leibler..
Candidly Speaking From Jerusalem..
23 march '16..

President Barack Obama’s determination to downgrade U.S. international power has generated massive global instability and chaos with especially ominous implications for Israel.

The Obama policies have undermined longstanding alliances within the Western bloc. By supporting the Muslim Brotherhood and allying with terrorist and rogue states like Iran, the U.S. has alienated Arab states such as Egypt and Saudi Arabia, which consider themselves abandoned and betrayed.

The wooing and groveling toward Iran has empowered the world’s leading Islamic terrorist state, enabled it to become a threshold nuclear power and exacerbated the conflict between the Shiites and Sunnis, which has led to the emergence of new Islamic barbarian groups like ISIS. The Islamic fundamentalists have reintroduced the Dark Ages to the region in which mass murder, rape and beheadings of civilians have become rampant.

Obama’s vacillating policies have resulted in the weakening of Arab states like Syria and Libya with consequent horrendous casualties and the displacement of millions. When controlled by the despotic Moammar Gadhafi, Libya had voluntarily abrogated its nuclear ambitions and undertaken to eschew terrorism. Obama’s enthusiasm to “democratize” the country led to the overthrow of the dictatorship, the assassination of the American ambassador and the transformation of Libya into a major terrorist launching pad which may ultimately necessitate military intervention.

The mayhem and terror in the region has created a severe refugee crisis which could accelerate the demise of the European Union and permanently alter the demographic base of Europe even leading to the erosion of European civilization.

The downgraded U.S. influence enabled President Vladimir Putin to reassert Russia as a major global power and achieve greater influence in the Middle East than the Soviets ever attained. Most Arab states today regard Russia as a more reliable ally than the U.S.

On top of all this, Obama’s domestic political legacy has led to widespread alienation against the entire political establishment and the emergence of populist candidates, such as Bernie Sanders and Donald Trump, who are supported merely because they challenge the existing order. At the same time, it is extraordinary that according to surveys, the leading candidates of both the Republican and Democratic parties, Trump and Hillary Clinton, respectively, are detested by half of their own party constituencies.

The Obama policies have led to uniquely Jewish negative repercussions:

The hostility to the Israeli government by its principal ally has provided enormous impetus to its adversaries. The double standards employed by the administration and classification of Israel as morally equivalent to the terrorists and the failure to directly reprimand Palestinian leaders engaged in incitement to murder Jews and sanctification of the killers as national “martyrs” — reflect morally outrageous behavior. At a time when almost half a million Syrians were butchered and 4 million displaced from their homes, the focus of U.S. ire was against Israeli construction of homes even in the Jewish neighborhoods of east Jerusalem. This blatant hostility by the Obama administration provided global encouragement to anti-Israeli forces and gave the green light to the Europeans to pressure Israel to make further unilateral concessions and recognize the indefensible 1949 armistice lines as the basis for permanent borders. In Europe, it is widely believed that Israelis behave like Nazis with genocidal intentions toward the Arabs and represent a greater threat to peace than rogue states like North Korea or Iran.

Wednesday, March 23, 2016

Yes or No. Will the University of California Support anti-Semitic anti-Zionism?

...Needless to say, anti-Semitic anti-Zionist students and professors claim that their hatred of Jewish people, via their hatred of the Jewish State, is a matter of free speech. They should be allowed to defame Israel, and thereby defame the great majority of Jewish people, as a matter of liberal democracy, despite the fact that such defamation tends to result in violence against the Jewish people and young Jewish students on campus.

Michael Lumish..
Israel Thrives..
23 March '16..

Tammi Rossman-Benjamin will kick your ass in a New York minute... but that is why I like her.

She has alerted me to the fact, and wants me to alert you to the fact, that University of California officials will vote today, Wednesday the 23rd of March, to include anti-Zionism as a form of discrimination that is unacceptable on campus.

For us locals, if not for Jews everywhere, this is a pretty big matter.

According to Teresa Watanabe of the Los Angeles Times:

The inclusion immediately drew sharply divergent reactions, with pro-Israel groups hailing it as a needed step to protect Jewish students from hostility and those supporting Palestinian rights criticizing it as a naked attempt to suppress criticism of the Jewish state.

The fact of the matter, as Tammi Rossman-Benjamin and her partners at the AMCHA Initiative have well demonstrated, is that anti-Semitic anti-Zionists on university campuses throughout the United States kick around Jewish students.

The reason that they do not like Jewish students is because they do not like the Jewish State of Israel or because they are racist against Jews.

If they despise Israel it is due to an acceptable and discriminatory racist double-standard that impales that country - the country of my people - as a terrible violator of human rights, while giving its far worse human rights violator neighbors a pass entirely. The truth is that California university students and professors generally do not care if ISIS buries Yazidi children alive or sell prepubescent girls into sexual slavery, but they very much care that the Jews of the Middle East dare to defend themselves against never-ending Arab-Muslim aggression.

For centuries Jewish self-defense has been seen, among westerners, as a form of aggression and continues to be seen as so on California university campuses.

The fact, of course, is that the Arab-Muslim world, surrounding little Israel, is rife with racism, homophobia, misogyny, and genocidal anti-Semitism, yet racist anti-Zionist students, with the encouragement of anti-Zionist professors such as Rabab Abdulhadi at San Francisco State University, just love to kick around the Jews within venues like "Israel Apartheid Week."

PRCS hosts terror glorification event. Also a BBC news source - by Hadar Sela

“Every year the Palestinian Authority and Fatah celebrate the anniversary of the most lethal terror attack in Israel’s history by honoring the female terrorist Dalal Mughrabi who led it. This year, one such celebration was hosted by the office of the Palestinian Red Crescent, which is under the International Red Cross.”

Hadar Sela..
BBC Watch..
22 March '16..

Regular readers of BBC News reports concerning the Palestinian-Israeli conflict will not infrequently come across information sourced from the Palestinian Red Crescent Society’s Ramallah and Gaza branches. For example:

“There were clashes in several places in the occupied West Bank, with the Red Crescent saying seven Palestinians suffered injuries from live fire”.

And:

“Scores of Palestinians were wounded in the violence across the occupied territories, including East Jerusalem, the Palestinian Red Crescent said.”

As readers may recall, the Palestinian Red Crescent Society was one of the sources relied upon by UNOCHA for the compilation of casualty figures and civilian/combatant ratios in the Gaza Strip during the 2014 conflict between Israel and Hamas. Those highly dubious figures were unquestioningly quoted, promoted – and defended – by the BBC during and after the conflict without any independent verification having been carried out.

(Read Full Post)

Updates throughout the day at http://calevbenyefuneh.blogspot.com. If you enjoy "Love of the Land", please be a subscriber. Just put your email address in the "Subscribe" box on the upper right-hand corner of the page.Twitter updates at LoveoftheLand as well as our Love of the Land page at Facebook which has additional pieces of interest besides that which is posted on the blog. Also check-out This Ongoing War by Frimet and Arnold Roth. An excellent blog, very important work as well as a big vote to follow our good friend Kay Wilson on Twitter.
.

The Iranian Missile Photo That CNN Missed - by Tamar Sternthal

...CNN could not independently confirm the information. So CAMERA has helped CNN, directing editors to a photograph of the missile with anti-Israel graffiti which appeared in the Iranian media.

Tamar Sternthal..
CAMERA Snapshots..
21 March '16..

Two CNN articles erroneously reported this month that Iranian media have not published photographs of the missiles emblazoned with the Hebrew words "Israel must be wiped off the earth," and that CNN could not independently confirm the information. So CAMERA has helped CNN, directing editors to a photograph of the missile with anti-Israel graffiti which appeared in the Iranian media.

On March 15, Barbara Starr wrote ("U.S. official raises Iran rocket fears; Tehran denies tests are illegal"):

The missiles, capable of reaching Iran's archenemy Israel, were marked with a statement in Hebrew reading "Israel must be wiped off the Earth," Iran's semiofficial Fars News Agency reported.

The phrase originates from a remark made by the Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini, the founder of Iran's Islamic revolution. CNN has not independently confirmed this report, and Iranian media have not shown photographs of the message.

Tuesday, March 22, 2016

Terrorism is terrorism, wherever it takes place. No ifs, no buts. - by Ilya Meyer

No ifs, no buts. The EU is a civil society that deserves to enjoy a civil life in uncompromised security. That said, we should never, EVER, have any faith in a single word that Europe, the EU, have to say on Israel or its uncompromised security.

Ilya Meyer..
ilyameyer.com/..
22 March '16..






My heart goes out to the victims and their families in Brussels.

The Prime Minister of Belgium says that “this was an attack on the capital of Europe, the EU is at war”.

Excuse me, but say that again?

Israel experiences precisely this kind of violence on a daily basis, carried out by precisely the same terrorists, following precisely the same ideology and using precisely the same methods.

Europe, the EU, constantly attack Israel for taking necessary steps to prevent this type of carnage.

Yet it takes just 1 (ONE) single such attack in Brussels to put all of Europe, the entire EU, on a war footing?

Excuse me, but does hypocrisy really have no limits?

There is absolutely no question that we all support whatever measures Europe, the EU, may take to prevent further atrocities of this kind.

No ifs, no buts. The EU is a civil society that deserves to enjoy a civil life in uncompromised security.

That said, we should never, EVER, have any faith in a single word that Europe, the EU, have to say on Israel or its uncompromised security.

Today’s atrocity in Brussels ought to have made that abundantly clear to everyone.

Surprise? More Palestinian Empty Threats

...For Abbas, security coordination is indeed "sacred": it is keeping him in power and stopping Hamas from taking over the West Bank. Hence the security coordination -- in Abbas's words -- is very important for the Palestinian Authority - perhaps more than thwarting Hamas terror attacks against Israel. Abbas has a problem. He cannot tell his people that security coordination with Israel is what is keeping him on the throne. The sacredness of security coordination is a topic for Israeli ears only. So what are the threats about? Money.

Abbas to the world: "Send more money or we
will cut off security cooperation with Israel."

Left: Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud
Abbas with French President François Hollande.
Right: Abbas with top European Union officials
 Federica Mogherini and Jean-Claude Juncker.
Khaled Abu Toameh..
Gatestone Institute..
21 March '16..

The Palestinian Authority's endless threats to suspend security coordination with Israel are a carefully crafted bluff designed to extort more funds from Western donors, scare the Israeli public and provide a cover for its refusal to talk peace with Israel.

Many Palestinians say these threats are also intended for "internal consumption" -- namely to appease Hamas and other radical factions and to refute charges that the Palestinian Authority (PA) is betraying its people by "collaborating" with Israel.

Hamas has conditioned "reconciliation" with President Mahmoud Abbas's ruling Fatah faction in the West Bank on Fatah ending all forms of security coordination with Israel. Hamas claims that the security coordination is directed mostly against its members and supporters in the West Bank.

Over the past several years, PA security forces have rounded up hundreds of Hamas men in an attempt to prevent the Islamist movement from establishing bases of power in the West Bank.

Hardly a week has passed during the past few months in which a senior Palestinian Authority official does not threaten to cut off security ties with Israel. Some officials in Ramallah have even claimed that the PA has already taken a decision to suspend not only security coordination with Israel, but also political and economic relations as well.

PA officials are saying that their threats, which until now have been so much dust in the wind, will be realized next month.

"April is going to be the turning point," declared Jamal Muheissen, member of the Fatah Central Committee. "This is a month that will witness changes with regards to several issues that can no longer be delayed or marginalized. April will witness the complete and public suspension of security coordination [with Israel]. This will be the first step taken by the Palestinian leadership."

This sounds curiously familiar: nearly a year has passed since leaders from the Palestinian Authority and Fatah first announced their decision to halt all forms of security coordination between the PA and Israel.

Anti-Israel Hate at the United Church of Christ - It’s Getting Ugly

...The United Church of Christ has a problem. Last summer, its General Synod singled out the Jewish State for condemnation while remaining silent about the ongoing genocide of Christians and Yezidis in Iraq and Syria. And while the rest of the country is starting to finally come around to acknowledging the horror of this genocide, UCC pastors and peace activists still continue to singularly assail the Jewish State with hateful rhetoric and propaganda. Like I said, it’s getting ugly.

Dexter Van Zile..
Algemeiner.com..
21 March '16..

The passage of a BDS resolution at the United Church of Christ (UCC)’s 2015 General Synod highlighted the presence of anti-Israel hate within the denomination. Not everyone who belongs to or works for the UCC — a liberal Protestant denomination with 900,000 members — hates Israel or Jews. Still, there is a contingent of activists and clergy within the denomination who specialize in combining religious piety with contempt for the Jewish homeland and its supporters.

It’s getting ugly.

These Israel-haters started coming out of the woodwork in early February, with the publication of two Lenten Meditations produced by UCC pastors. Lent, the 40 days before Easter, is a time when Christians are supposed to engage in introspection, fasting and prayer; but in 2016, two UCC clergy members used Lent as an opportunity to bash Israel in some pretty ugly ways.

Rev. Loren McGrail, a UCC pastor, produced a Lenten meditation that relied on dishonest articles from Palestinian news outlets to inform her readers about the conflict. One of the articles falsely claimed that Israel did not arrest or punish any of the people responsible for a 2015 arson attack in Duma that killed an 11-month-old Arab baby and his parents.

The article, published by Palestine National News in January 2016, stated explicitly that Israel did not hold anyone accountable for the Duma attack, because “the evidence against the Jewish suspects was ‘not enough’ to try them.”

Wrong. Israeli officials did arrest and indict a 21-year-old Israeli Jew and an unnamed minor for setting the fire — weeks before the PNN published its story.

The same article also falsely suggested that Israel did not punish anyone for the murder of Mohammad Abu Khdeir in July 2014. In fact, Israel arrested the perpetrators soon after the attack, and they are currently in jail.

Fortunately, the UCC removed the article after CAMERA exposed its propagandistic nature.

The UCC did the right thing in response to McGrail’s screed, but she was not the only UCC pastor who tried to pass off anti-Israel propaganda as a Lenten meditation. Rev. Diane Dulin, a retired UCC pastor from Oregon who now works for the anti-Israel Kairos USA produced a text even uglier than McGrail’s.

Her text, which was promoted by the Episcopal Church, declared that the Zionist interpretation of scripture proffers a “word of death and not of life.”

What Even-Handed on Israel Means - by Jonathan Tobin

...That’s why friends of Israel don’t have to wait until Donald Trump becomes president to know what an even-handed stance toward Israel looks like. It’s a policy that strengthens terror and makes the already remote chances of peace even more unlikely. With respect to the Middle East, the U.S. needs a president who is prepared to learn from Obama’s errors. Unfortunately, it looks as though both Hillary Clinton and Trump seem prepared to repeat them. If Israelis worry about having to pay the same price in blood for such folly in the coming years that they’ve paid under Obama, who can blame them?


Jonathan S. Tobin..
Commentary Magazine..
21 March '16..

Many in the pro-Israel community are upset about Donald Trump’s vow to be neutral between Israel and the Palestinians in future Middle East peace negotiations. Trump’s speech tonight at the AIPAC conference will be closely scrutinized to see if he walks those comments back or how exactly he chooses to navigate that issue even as many of those in attendance are just as if not more upset about his dog whistling comments about race and prejudice as well as his encouragement of violence at his rallies. But those AIPAC attendees wanting to know what a genuinely even-handed speech about Israel and the Palestinians sounded like didn’t have to wait until Trump appears on Monday night. Vice President Joe Biden spoke on Sunday and delivered a textbook definition of even-handed diplomacy when he placed equal blame for the failure to make progress toward peace on both Israelis and Palestinians.

That isn’t the way some Jewish supporters of the Obama administration will characterize Biden’s remarks. They will point to Biden’s extravagant vows of an “unyielding” commitment to Israel’s safety and security, his touting of the military aid the Jewish state has received from the administration, and his criticism of the Palestinian Authority for refusing to condemn terrorism, including the attack in Jaffa during his recent visit to the country in which a U.S. army vet was slain by a terrorist.

But while Biden sought to celebrate all that the Obama administration had done for the Jewish state and to justify the Iran nuclear deal, the real message of his speech was no different from the stand for which Trump has been correctly blasted by friends of Israel. When it comes to the standoff over peace, even amid Biden’s folksy and emotional appeals — a message honed over the course of the last four decades as he wooed pro-Israel voters and donors — was an unmistakable charge that the Jewish state is as much to blame for the lack of peace as the Palestinians.

According to Biden, “actions on either side undermine trust only take us further away from the path of peace.” He correctly labeled the efforts by Israel’s foes to isolate it in the international community, as well as Palestinian terrorism, as examples of how the other side undermines peace. But he treated Israeli settlement building as morally equivalent to terror and the “apartheid state” slurs. He demanded that Israel provide a “little show-me” to demonstrate its goodwill and desire for peace.

To liberal American ears, such even-handed assessments of the peace process sound fair. But, like Biden’s attempts to defend the Iran nuclear deal as a boost to Israel’s security rather than a game-changing event that makes the region much more dangerous, the administration’s “plague on both your houses” approach to the peace process is tone-deaf to the reality on the ground. Even worse, despite his misty-eyed rhetoric about how much Israel means to him, even handed diplomacy not only doesn’t serve the cause of peace, it also helps incite more violence.

Monday, March 21, 2016

Condemn the murder of my father and Abbas' embrace of his murderer

Today, as an Israeli son whose father was brutally struck down by a Palestinian terrorist, I address the United Nations Human Rights Council and issue a challenge to the UN’s leader: condemn the murder of my father and Palestinian President Abbas’ embrace of his murderer.

Human Rights Voices..
21 March '16..

Micah Lakin Avni, who is the chief executive of the Peninsula Group based in Tel Aviv, also spoke at the UN Human Rights Council in Geneva today on behalf of the Touro Institute on Human Rights and the Holocaust.



Today, as an Israeli son whose father was brutally struck down by a Palestinian terrorist, I address the United Nations Human Rights Council and issue a challenge to the UN’s leader: condemn the murder of my father and Palestinian President Abbas’ embrace of his murderer.

My father, Richard Lakin, was a kind gentle person. An elementary school principal who educated thousands of children, teachers and parents. A life-long activist dedicated to promoting human rights, social justice and peaceful coexistence. In the 1960s he marched with Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. At home in Connecticut, he initiated and oversaw the integration of a white suburban elementary school and co-founded one of the first integrated summer camps. He moved to Israel in the 1980s and founded a school in which Jewish, Christian and Muslim children studied English together as a second language. His book “Teaching as an Act of Love” set forth his educational philosophy with the message “every child is a miracle” that needs to be nurtured with love. His Facebook page featured a picture of two children, Jewish and Arab, sitting arm-in-arm under the word “Coexist.”

On October 13, 2016 two Palestinian terrorists attacked a bus full of innocent passengers in Jerusalem. It was a vicious and brutal attack. They shot my 76-year old father in the head. They then stabbed him multiple times after he fell to the ground, severing most of his vital organs. The knife broke in the process. The scene was horrific. Screaming wounded, bodies and blood everywhere. My dad was rushed to the hospital with the giant knife blade still lodged in his stomach.

UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon visited my father in the ICU before he died. We stood next to my unconscious father, a beautiful man who once read books to his granddaughters, but now kept alive by machines. He died two weeks later and Ban sent my mother an emotional condolence letter in which he promised to “speak out against terrorism and incitement.”

But the Secretary-General and his UN never publicly condemned the Palestinian terrorists who murdered my father, nor the years of Palestinian incitement that fuels this brutality. On February 3, 2016 Palestinian leader Mohamad Abbas met the terrorist’s father, calling the man’s son not a terrorist who murdered innocent civilians, but a “martyr” who has gone to heaven. Ban reacted with silence. Just as he been silent for years allowing wanton Palestinian incitement to hatred and violence in his UN schools in Gaza and the West Bank.

The UN Office at Geneva’s webpage “UN Response to Acts of Terrorism” lists terror attacks and UN condemnations. Richard Lakin is not on this list. In fact, not a single Israeli victim of the latest wave of Palestinian terror is on it.

America, Israel and the Moral Bankruptcy of the Progressive-Left - by Michael Lumish

...On the progressive-left, Israel is the Jew among nations. Just as prior to establishment of the state of Israel Europeans tended to ascribe a host of negative characteristics to the Jewish people, so today they ascribe those same specific characteristics to the Jewish state and they do so... gallingly enough, hypocritically enough... under the banner of social justice. For 2,000 years we lived in diaspora, that is, we lived or died according to the pleasure of non-Jews. For 1,300 years we lived as second and third-class non-citizens under the imperialist boot of Muslim rule, i.e., as dhimmis. And today, directly after the historical moment in which we re-took our freedom, progressives tell us that the institution within which we manifest that freedom, the state of Israel, is a racist, colonialist, imperialist, apartheid country which, if it should not be dismantled as the national homeland for the Jewish people, must jump through whatever hoops they lay down.

Michael Lumish..
Israel Thrives..
19 March '16..

(Also published at the Elder of Ziyon)

{Author's note - this is a slightly edited retread from a few years ago. I thought that it was worth revisiting.}

The progressive movement's main claim to political legitimacy is a moral claim. The movement claims to stand for social justice and equality of rights throughout the world. Any legitimacy the left has as a political movement is grounded in the notion of universal human rights. But if the left has quietly abandoned that ideal, which it has, then it loses both moral and political legitimacy. After all, if the left does not stand for universal human rights, then just what in this world does it stand for?

The sad truth is that the left has abandoned its core reason to be. By holding different people, and different countries, to different moral standards it has effectively abandoned its alleged core values. One cannot claim to stand for social justice, after all, if you only care about social justice for some people, but not others. If you constantly speak out against supposed Israeli human rights abuses but remain silent about the truly horrific situations in Darfur or Congo or Syria... circumstances that make the Arab-Israel conflict look like a picnic on a summer Sunday afternoon... then you cannot claim to stand for universal human rights and, therefore, any claims you may have for moral or political leadership, as a member of the left, are entirely unfounded.

This is the situation that we find ourselves in, currently, and it probably represents at least part of the reason why many Jews are becoming more and more dissatisfied with the Democratic Party and the progressive movement. Most diaspora Jewish supporters of Israel are people who at one time, if not currently, considered themselves on the progressive-left. Certainly, I did. As someone who grew up in the political aftermath of the counterculture and the New Left, I was impressed with the ideals of those movements. I was impressed with the counterculture for its apparent spontaneity, its anti-authoritarian values, and its sense of community. I was impressed with the New Left for standing against jingoism, for its anti-war agenda, and for its championing of the human rights of women and Gay people and other minorities.

Today, looking back on the movement that was for decades my political home, what I see are the ruins of what was and the rank hypocrisy of what is. The left has essentially broken itself on Israel's back and they don't even know it, yet. The reason for this is that if, as a movement, the progressive-left intends to constantly fire-off Katyushas of Hatred and Qassams of Malice toward Tel Aviv, while snuggying up to Iran, then they lose all moral legitimacy. This is particularly true given the fact that the left could hardly care less about the 5.5 million dead in the Congo, about Tibetans living under Chinese occupation, about rape as a tactic of war in Darfur, about the hanging of Gay people from cranes in Tehran, or about an Arab and Muslim world rife with anti-Semitism, homophobia, and gender apartheid.

In this way the left, which claims to be both moral and anti-racist proves itself to be, in fact, neither.

On the progressive-left, Israel is the Jew among nations. Just as prior to establishment of the state of Israel Europeans tended to ascribe a host of negative characteristics to the Jewish people, so today they ascribe those same specific characteristics to the Jewish state and they do so... gallingly enough, hypocritically enough... under the banner of social justice. For 2,000 years we lived in diaspora, that is, we lived or died according to the pleasure of non-Jews. For 1,300 years we lived as second and third-class non-citizens under the imperialist boot of Muslim rule, i.e., as dhimmis. And today, directly after the historical moment in which we re-took our freedom, progressives tell us that the institution within which we manifest that freedom, the state of Israel, is a racist, colonialist, imperialist, apartheid country which, if it should not be dismantled as the national homeland for the Jewish people, must jump through whatever hoops they lay down. If Israel fails to jump through each and every one of those hoops then clearly they do not want peace and thus deserve whatever they get.

Well, some of us have definitely had enough of this nonsense.

Abbas. Never held accountable for anything, obviously not considered disappointing

...The real problem is that while Benjamin Netanyahu constantly comes under scrutiny for whatever he does, Mahmoud Abbas is never held accountable for anything. Not by the United Nations. Not by the world community. Not by the international media. And not by President Obama, who obviously does not consider Abbas to be disappointing.

Emily Gian..
J-Wire..
18 March '16..

There is a point of view among many students of Middle Eastern politics that all of its problems would be solved if Israel ended its occupation of the territories captured during the 1967 Six-Day-War and handed them to the Palestinians.

After all, no country really wants to control the lives of other people, and in doing so, such a situation weighs heavily on Israel, its people and its democratic values.

Of course, the reality is far from simple as we have seen in more than two decades since we witnessed the famous scenes on the White House Lawns in September 1993 when Israeli and Palestinian leaders shook hands and penned an agreement that was meant to lead to an all-embracing peace in the region.

Volumes have been written since that day about why things did not turn out the way we thought they would. Fingers have been pointed and accusations made against both sides as well as against the interlocutors – those who were supposed to be assisting the parties in reaching the goal of two states living side by side in peace.

Looking at things in March 2016, one could be forgiven for believing that the peace process has floundered because, at a point in time, it must have entered some kind of “Bizzaro World”.

Last week, the Times of Israel and other media outlets told us that American President “Obama sees Netanyahu as most disappointing of all Mideast leaders”.

I found this curious because, leaving aside Syria’s Bashar al-Assad who has barrel-bombed his own people, and the Hamas leadership in Gaza which preaches genocide against Jews and the destruction of the State of Israel, and a handful of other despots, one has to wonder why President Obama is constantly looking aside when it comes to the behaviour of the Palestinian Authority Chairman, Mahmoud Abbas.

After all, at the very time we were being informed that Obama was so unimpressed by Israel’s Prime Minister, Abbas was making a fool of Obama’s Vice President Joe Biden, who was visiting the region to test whether something could be done to revive the moribund peace process.

As it happens, Biden’s visit coincided with a terror attack in Jaffa, which claimed the life of American citizen Taylor Force, a West Point graduate from Texas who was stabbed to death by a Palestinian. Force was a non-Jewish American. Two other people stabbed in the attack were Muslims.

Biden was in town in the hope of persuading the Palestinian leadership to issue a “condemnation” of the six-month reign of terror that has been gripping the country.

If there was ever a time to send a strong message to his people, and indeed to the world, that this slow-burning intifada is going to get them nowhere, that was Abbas’ time.

But all Abbas could muster was to send his condolences for the death of an American and, at the same time, he stressed that “the occupation authorities have killed 200 Palestinians over the past five months”. In other words, Abbas was equally concerned with the deaths of Palestinian stabbers and shooters as he was with the murdered American citizen. Even less subtle was Abbas’ Fatah faction which praised the murderer and called him a “martyr”. Fatah quickly deleted this post from its site.

In 1973, Abba Eban said that the “Arabs never miss an opportunity to miss an opportunity”. This was one of those times.

NY Times Almost Gets It Right - by Daniel Pomerantz

New York Times readers deserve all the news that’s fit to print, not just the portions that fit a specific, and misleading, agenda.

Daniel Pomerantz..
Honest Reporting..
20 March '16..

This week in her New York Times column called “Ramallah Journal,” Diaa Hadid examined corruption and intimidation within the Palestinian Authority legislature. The article was as important as it was unusual, in shining a spotlight on the problems in Palestinian government that create challenges for Israelis and Palestinians alike. New York Times Public Editor Margaret Sullivan has addressed the importance of this kind of coverage: pointing out that New York Times Readers were not receiving the full context about how Palestinian leadership actually triggers much of the violence that Israelis and Palestinians face.

Yet even in a piece about Palestinian government, Hadid took a detour to criticize Israel, and in doing so fell short of accepted journalistic standards. Referring to Palestinian lawmaker Khalida Jarrar, Hadid wrote, “…the Israeli military issued an order limiting her movement. (She was later arrested on charges that have not been made public.)”



What’s the Truth?