Monday, June 29, 2009

Orange Breakdown

From "The Eye of the Storm"
Batya Medad

Pre-Disengagement, the opposition took on the color orange as its symbol. The struggle was waged so poorly, it made me wonder how seriously Moetzet YESHA wanted to win. I joined the many thousands in wearing an orange bracelet. On the bracelet you can read a slogan:

יהודי לא מגרש יהודי
Yehudi lo migaraish Yehudi
A Jew Doesn't Banish/Evict Another Jew

During the tense and unpleasant times before Disengagement, especially after the Bayit Yehudi, Jewish Home, leaders were arrested and Moetzet YESHA Council took over, I became totally disenchanted with the "orange" leadership. At this point, it doesn't pay to go into detail, but certainly, if they had been competent Israel would still be sovereign and Jews would be living in Gush Katif.

The struggle was waged so poorly, it made me wonder how seriously Moetzet YESHA wanted to win.

Regardless, just like I believe that we must support the IDF, the Israeli Army, despite its faults and we must support the State of Israel and fly its flag despite all the wrong it does, I keep an orange ribbon on my door and kept orange bracelet on my wrist.

Over the years, the orange became dull, dark and dirty, and this week it finally broke and fell off.

Yes, my wrist no longer proclaims/advertises my opposition to one of the most evil government decrees ever.
The "orange leadership" never provided good leadership. Its monument is the Arab terror base where Jews once lived and thrived in Gush Katif. The DP's, evictees, are trying, despite their poverty and the apathy of the Israeli Government and most of the Jewish People, to rebuild their lives.

There was never a mass movement for Jewish civil rights in Gush Katif, unlike the support for Jews in the Golan. That's why we're still in the Golan instead of it being a Syrian base for anti-Israeli terrorism, the way it was prior to the 1967 Six Days War.

As was the case with Batya, my orange bracelet also broke this week and now resides on the shelf. However I personally never gave to or assumed that Moetzet Yesha was responsible to lead or win the struggle for Gush Katif. Many have suggested what could have been done yet did not step forward to lead when needed, others mastered the art of rhetoric which had no significance beyond self promotion. Also, until today, I have yet to abandon the Blue and White, for the Orange, perhaps a more, or the most significant reason the Golan remains today. I believe there is yet something to learn, that to move ahead we will need to act as a people, and not just as a sector. Our choice.

1 comment:

  1. Thanks for posting this. Lack of reliable leadership is a big problem. It's better for us to go forward than remain attached to past failures.