Wednesday, September 7, 2011

Stern - Identifying Cars, Seeing Threats

Paula S. Stern
A Soldier's Mother
07 September '11


http://israelisoldiersmother.blogspot.com/2011/09/identifying-cars-seeing-threats.html

I had an interesting conversation with Shmulik while we were driving the other day. As we were entering a traffic circle, a car to our right edged in more than he should have. I was watching to see that the car would stop and didn't notice another car that also came closer than it should have.

I said something to Shmulik about the first car and he asked me if I'd seen the other. I admitted that I had not seen it (he was driving, so it wasn't like we were in any danger). He asked me what type of car had come towards us on the right. "A white one," I admitted a bit sheepishly.

My sons (Elie and Shmulik and probably Davidi as well) can all tell cars by their make, their model and their year. I know some models, fewer makes, and no years. That's when Shmulik told me how his commanding officer used to quiz him after he passed a car "what car was that?" S. would ask him; how many people in the car?

He was training Shmulik to be more aware, to notice the details and that remains with him today. He notices things. It helps in his work as a security job; it is a part of their lives in general. They scan the hills in certain areas where Arabs are known to throw rocks; they watch if someone suspicious comes around.

Fresnozionism - Answering the demographic argument

Fresnozionism.org
06 September '11

http://fresnozionism.org/2011/09/answering-the-demographic-argument/


On Sunday I found myself ‘stunned’ by the remarks of Hedva Radovanitz, a former officer of the New Israel Fund (NIF) who said that she believed that

in 100 years Israel would be majority Arab and that the disappearance of a Jewish state would not be the tragedy that Israelis fear since it would become more democratic.

Today I understand that I shouldn’t have been surprised. This point of view is not really all that rare among the Jewish Left.

I suppose the stunning part is the way they can throw away the idea of a Jewish state so easily, when creating it was so difficult. Apparently keeping it may be as difficult or more so.

To my surprise, I received an answer from another former board member of the NIF and a member of the steering committee of Shatil, its “operational arm” in Israel. I don’t have permission to use his name, but he is a serious academic, someone that nobody would call an extremist. Here is what he wrote:

Rennert - NY Times regurgitates Mahmoud Abbas' propaganda lies

Leo Rennert
American Thinker
06 September '11

http://www.americanthinker.com/blog/2011/09/ny_times_regurgitates_mahmoud_abbas_propaganda_lies.html

On Sept. 5, Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas invited 20 left-wing Israeli intellectuals to his office in Ramallah. Abbas' Israeli guests, in opposition to their own government, proceeded to urge him to go to the UN and seek a unilateral declaration of Palestinian statehood. Journalists were invited to cover the meeting, reports Ethan Bronner, the Jerusalem bureau chief of the New York Times, who dutifully accompanied the group. ("Abbas Affirms Palestinian Bid for U.N. Membership," Sept. 6, page A6).

Bronner, in a four-column spread, uncritically passes on to Times readers Abbas's claims that his UN bid is in sync with getting to direct negotiations with Israel, that he is committed to a two-state solution and that his goal is for a "Palestinian state and Israel to live in peace and security next to one another."

"We don't want to delegitimize Israel," Abbas tells his guests. "We want to legitimize ourselves. We are going to complain that as Palestinians we have been under occupation for 63 years"

At this point, any reporter worth his salt might break in and ask Abbas a couple of pertinent questions, such as:

--"President Abbas, how can you say that you're not delegitimizing Israel when you teach Palestinian children that 'Palestine' includes all of Israel, when you keep glorifying as holy martyrs suicide bombers, and when even your supposed two-state plan would strip the Western Wall, Judaism's holiest shrine, from Israel?"

Gordon - The End of Land for Peace?

Evelyn Gordon
Commentary/Contentions
06 September '11

http://www.commentarymagazine.com/2011/09/06/end-of-land-for-peace/

The deteriorating Egyptian-Israeli relationship has produced an interesting side effect: For the first time in 30 years, Israelis are seriously questioning the wisdom of “land for peace.” Even veteran land-for-peace advocates like former Jerusalem Post editor-in-chief David Makovsky now acknowledge war with Egypt is no longer unthinkable. Recognition is growing that Egypt’s nonstop demands to boost its forces in Sinai threaten the Israeli-Egyptian treaty’s main achievement: the demilitarization of Sinai, which ensured Egypt could never attack Israel by surprise.

Hence Elliot Jager, another erstwhile land-for-peace advocate (and former senior Jerusalem Post editor), warned in Jewish Ideas Daily today that “If the treaty with Egypt must be gutted in order to save it, something may be terribly wrong with the underlying land-for-peace approach.” Guy Bechor, a regular columnist for the mass-circulation daily Yedioth Ahronoth, bluntly declared the land-for-peace formula “dead” last week. Even Akiva Eldar of Haaretz, a diehard leftist who still wants an Israeli withdrawal to the pre-1967 lines, admitted despairingly after last month’s cross-border terror attacks from Sinai that “When the border between Israel and Egypt is open to murderers, it’s harder to condemn Israel’s leaders for refusing to utter the words ‘negotiation on the basis of the ’67 borders.’”

As Bechor noted, the land-for-peace approach has several inherent problems. First, it encourages the Arabs to view peace as a concession Israel must pay for rather than something of value to them. Second, it trades an easily-reversed asset (peace) for an almost irreversible one (land), which undermines deterrence: The Arabs can abrogate their side of the bargain without fear of losing the quid pro quo they received. I’d also add a third: It encourages war by making aggression cost-free. After all, the land in question was captured in a defensive war against three Arab states in 1967; agreeing to return every last inch – as Israel did in Sinai and Gaza and is now expected to do in the West Bank – thus sends the message Arabs risk no permanent territorial losses by attacking Israel.

All these evils are obviously compounded when territory is given to people who loathe Israel (as both Egyptians and Palestinians do). Many Westerners seem to think this hostility would disappear if Israel would just “end the occupation.” Prize-winning reporter Anthony Shadid, for instance, asserted in the New York Times last month Egypt’s current hostility stems from “deep popular resentment over the plight of Palestinians,” thus implying it would vanish were this plight alleviated.

There’s only one problem with this theory: As a 2007 Pew Global Attitudes poll found, fully 80 percent of Egyptians think “Palestinians’ rights cannot be taken care of if Israel exists.” In short, their problem isn’t Israel’s “occupation” of the West Bank, it’s Israel’s very existence. And 77 percent of Palestinians say the same.

It’s too late to reverse the withdrawal from Sinai, but it’s not too late to avoid repeating the same mistake in the West Bank. Thus, if Egypt’s new hostility awakens Israel to this danger in time, it will prove to have a silver lining.

If you enjoy "Love of the Land", please be a subscriber. Just put your email address in the "Subscribe" box on the upper right-hand corner of the page.
.

Medad - Will The Pals. Face Up to Their Responsibility?

This photoshopped poster says it all
Yisrael Medad
My Right Word
06 September '11

http://myrightword.blogspot.com/2011/09/will-pals-face-up-to-their.html


Dear Pals.,

You refuse, and have done so since time immemorial, to recognize Jewish national rights.

You weren't satisfied with the first territorial compromise in 1922, when the British Mandate power, suspended the right of Jews to close settlement in Trans Jordan.

You weren't satisfied with a proposal for an Arab Agency.

You didn't want the 1937 partition proposal.

You rejected the St. James Conference in 1939.

You engaged in terror from the beginning.

You practiced ethnic cleansing at Hebron, Shchem, Jenin, Gaza, Jerusalem, Atarot, Neveh Yaakov, Bet Haaravah, Gush Etzion and other locations.

You rejected the UN Partition recommendation of November 29, 1947.

You launched an aggressive war the next day and maintained it ever since.

You infiltrated across Israel's borders as fedayeen and then founded the PLO and Fatah. You never renounced the use of terror against civilians.

You refused the Autonomy proposal of Camp David 1977.

You violated the 1993 Oslo Accords and launched suicide-bomber attacks in our malls, restaurants and on our buses.

You backed out of the Clinton parameters of 2000-01.

You walked away from Ehud Olmert.

You received Gaza in 2005.

You are losers.

You broke it.

If you enjoy "Love of the Land", please be a subscriber. Just put your email address in the "Subscribe" box on the upper right-hand corner of the page.
.

Tuesday, September 6, 2011

Richman - Re: Obama’s Misguided UN Appeal to Abbas

Rick Richman
Commentary/Contentions
06 September '11

http://www.commentarymagazine.com/2011/09/05/obama-un-appeal-abbas/#more-766544


Let me add a footnote to Jonathan’s post about the Obama administration’s attempt to “bribe or cajole” the Palestinian Authority to forego seeking UN recognition of a state. It was clear back in April there was a different way to proceed — one that would not have wasted this crisis.

When Mahmoud Abbas announced his “reconciliation” with the terrorist group the PA was required under the Roadmap to dismantle, and moved to seek a determination of the boundaries of a Palestinian state through the UN (rather than through the negotiations required by the Roadmap), the U.S. should have seen the move not as something to be countered by pre-negotiation concessions by Israel or the U.S., but as a moment of truth for the putative Palestinian state: if the PA cannot meet its commitments under the Roadmap, there is no reason to believe it can meet its commitments under a peace agreement. The PA should have been given a choice: forego further attempts to run around the Roadmap, or forego further U.S. support for a Palestinian state.

The “reconciliation” agreement pledged new elections “within a year” — a transparent attempt to show the UN the two halves of the putative Palestinian state were united and ready to be recognized as a democratic state. The chances of those elections occurring are as likely as General Franco recovering, since Fatah and Hamas cannot live “side by side in peace and security”™ with each other, much less with Israel. But the U.S. should have held the PA to its word: hold your election, elect someone committed to peace with Israel and to prior agreements, or forget about further U.S. efforts to create a Palestinian state.

If the PA is not able to hold an election, or to elect leaders committed to prior agreements, or willing to negotiate without preconditions, or to make the concessions necessary for a state, the U.S. should have no interest in supporting such a state, much less making it a central part of U.S. foreign policy. Such a response to the PA stratagem would have placed the burden where it should have been, as J.E. Dyer has noted, and would have done so at a time when it was still possible for the PA to call off its self-destructive move. Instead, the Obama administration is coming to the end of an increasingly desperate effort to preserve a process the PA has already made clear it cannot complete.

If you enjoy "Love of the Land", please be a subscriber. Just put your email address in the "Subscribe" box on the upper right-hand corner of the page.
.

Weinberg - Gates’ Gripe

Ungrateful Bob Gates
David M. Weinberg
A Citadel Defending Zion
06 September '11

http://davidmweinberg.com/2011/09/06/gates-gripe/




So, Robert Gates is peeved with Israel. And why not? American defense and foreign policy leaders have done so well in handling the Middle East over the past few years! It's only sourpuss Israel that spoils Washington's track record, right?

Former U.S. Secretary of Defense Robert M. Gates, who left the job earlier this summer, has supposedly complained about Israel being an ungrateful ally. According to blogger Jeffery Goldberg, Gates said during one of his last meetings with senior officials that not only is “Netanyahu ungrateful, but he is also endangering his country by refusing to grapple with Israel’s growing isolation and with the demographic challenges it faces if it keeps control of the West Bank." The U.S. had "received nothing" from Israel on peace diplomacy in return for the many Obama administration upgrades in U.S.-Israel security cooperation, Gates reportedly said.

Gates's gripes are unsubstantiated on three levels. But I think that they also mask a deeper American failure and fatigue – that goes far beyond Israel.

First of all, Gates knows full well that recent upgrades in U.S.-Israel intelligence sharing and weapons development are to America's benefit as much as Israel's. Israel is not being "handed-out favors" for which it is ungrateful.

Secondly, the Obama Administration has ramped up such security cooperation mainly for its own reasons – to hold Israel back from attacking Iran. In other words, to handcuff Israel. Thank you very much.

Thirdly, the notion that Israel (Netanyahu) has not budged on diplomatic matters is simply wrong, even infuriating. Netanyahu's embrace of the two-state solution, his unprecedented settlement freeze and willingness to relate to the 1967 lines rubric – are callously dismissed by Gates as non-consequential. Note that the Palestinian Authority, which gets half a billion dollars in American aid and which has crudely stiffed American diplomacy for the past year, doesn't seem to annoy Gates. So I think the disrespect runs the other way around: It is Gates (and Obama) who are being churlishly ungrateful toward Netanyahu.

I suspect that there is more to the picture. The pique supposedly expressed by Gates (take it with a grain of salt when a Netanyahu-bashing journalist is the source) is a veneer under which lurks American strategic fatigue and multiple policy failures across the Middle East. Bashing Israel is but a weak cover for the sorry Obama/Gates record.

Balint - The Circles of Jewish Life: How A Brit Milah Closed Circles

Judy Lash Balint
www.kumah.org
05 September '11

http://www.kumah.org/2011/09/the-circles-of-jewish-life-how-a-brit-milah-closed-circles/



Earlier this evening, the brit milah of Yishai and Malkah Fleisher’s second child, Elazer Menachem, took place in their apartment in Maale HaZeitim, overlooking the Temple Mount. The brief ceremony that initiated the baby into the covenant of Abraham closed circles for several of the people who crammed into the Fleisher’s home to celebrate the occasion.

Yishai was born in Israel to a family who had managed to escape Leningrad in the 1970s, a few short years before his birth. The Fleishers, like many Russian Jews, were intellectuals whose Jewish identity had been rekindled by the Six-Day War. I met many families like the Fleishers when I traveled to the former Soviet Union in 1974, 1986 and 1989.

The Fleishers were amongst the fortunate ones who arbitrarily received visas for Israel after losing jobs and waiting for years to get out. Following several years of economic struggle in Israel, the family made the difficult decision to leave for the US, where Yishai and his brother and sister grew up.

Yishai is fluent in Russian, Hebrew and English, as is his mother, who in Hebrew addressed those who came to celebrate the brit, as she held her tiny new-born sabra grandson in her arms. In a voice filled with emotion, she marveled at the fact that after all her family’s wanderings, she was holding the second generation of sabras in her family. “At this special moment, we can’t forget all those whom we left behind in the forests of Ukraine; in the fields around Leningrad and in the trenches of Russia,” she said. “My grandson will never know such wanderings–he’s at home here in Jerusalem,” she whispered.

Tobin - Obama’s Misguided UN Appeal to Abbas

Jonathan S. Tobin
Commentary/Contentions
05 September '11

http://www.commentarymagazine.com/2011/09/05/palestinians-un-statehood-obama/

According to the New York Times, the Obama administration is going all out to try and bribe or cajole the Palestinian Authority into withdrawing its plan to ask the United Nations General Assembly to vote recognition of an independent Palestinian state. The United States, along with the diplomatic Quartet, intends to issue a new peace proposal favorable to the Palestinians in order to entice PA leader Mahmoud Abbas to step back from a confrontation in New York this month.

But this effort is based on a fundamental misreading of the Palestinians’ motivations for going to the UN. Abbas has pursued this tactic in order to avoid further negotiations with Israel–not get more diplomatic support from the West on settlements or borders. The administration also fails to understand that for all of the difficulties a U.S. veto of Palestinian statehood in the Security Council might entail for Washington, the decision to go to the UN poses a greater danger to Abbas and his Fatah Party than it does to the United States or Israel.

It is the Palestinians who stand to suffer the most from a measure they may have thought would benefit them.

The certain failure of a UN statehood initiative has set the stage for a vast outpouring of frustration when the Palestinians realize nothing has changed. This could seriously undermine the already tenuous legitimacy Abbas’ Fatah government possesses. Since the PA has established a false narrative that claims Palestinian attempts at conciliation with Israel were rejected — a palpable lie because it was Yasir Arafat who rejected Israeli offers of a Palestinian state in 2000 and 2001 and Abbas himself who did so in 2008 — the inevitable disappointment that will follow the UN vote will only strengthen the position of Fatah’s Hamas rivals. Though Israel and to a lesser extent the United States will take a beating in the court of international public opinion following a General Assembly vote, it is the PA that will suffer most.

The one party that would benefit from a post-September conflagration is Hamas. Under Hamas, Gaza has become the true face of Palestinian independence. Unlike Fatah in the West Bank, the terrorist group’s power is untrammeled. Though it retains the ability to launch terror attacks against Israel whenever it wants, Hamas represents a greater threat to the PA than to the Jewish state. The endgame of a third intifada will not be a Palestinian state or a reinvigorated peace process but a crippled Fatah that will be more dependent than ever on Israel and a strengthened Hamas.

That is why the PA has spent much of the summer hinting privately at their desire to avoid the confrontation in New York that they planned themselves. The problem for Abbas is the process he began is not so easily derailed. Abbas would clearly like to be able to find a way to avoid a diplomatic confrontation with the United States (and the possibility of a cutoff of American aid), but if the price of doing so is resuming negotiations with Israel, that will be just as problematic.

Seen in this light, rather than the U.S. seeking to bribe the Palestinians, it is Abbas who should be the supplicant. Though Israel will be battered in the UN debate, Abbas and Fatah are the biggest potential losers of this affair. The Obama administration should realize this and act accordingly.

If you enjoy "Love of the Land", please be a subscriber. Just put your email address in the "Subscribe" box on the upper right-hand corner of the page.
.

Elder - Abbas: "Palestinians have been under occupation for 63 years"

Elder of Ziyon
05 September '11

http://elderofziyon.blogspot.com/2011/09/abbas-palestinians-have-been-under.html


From NYT, in an interview with Mahmoud Abbas:

We don’t want to isolate Israel but to live with it in peace and security. We don’t want to delegitimize Israel. We want to legitimize ourselves.

All well and good - except for what he said immediately prior to this:

We are going to complain [at the UN] that as Palestinians we have been under occupation for 63 years.

How can one reconcile those two statements? If Israel has been occupying their land since its birth in 1948, doesn't that make Israel illegitimate?

(Somehow, I don't think he was referring to Jordanian occupation.)

The New York Times' Ethan Bronner, as usual, did not ask for clarification. And Mahmoud Abbas remains free to say whatever he wants to whatever audience he wants without fear of someone pointing out that he is a liar.

(h/t Dan)

If you enjoy "Love of the Land", please be a subscriber. Just put your email address in the "Subscribe" box on the upper right-hand corner of the page.
.

WSJ - A United Nations Miracle

Wall Street Journal
Review and Asia outlook
05 September '11

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424053111904716604576546643185160996.html

Israel is vindicated on the Gaza flotilla, but Turkey still pouts.

Here's a story for the man-bites-dog folder: The United Nations has conducted another inquiry into an Israeli military operation—and produced a report that mainly vindicates the Jewish state. And here, alas, is a story for the dog-bites-man folder: The Turkish government has responded to the U.N. report by withdrawing its ambassador from Tel Aviv and expelling Israel's from Ankara.

The Palmer report—named for the inquiry's chairman, former New Zealand Prime Minister Geoffrey Palmer—was commissioned by the U.N.'s Secretary General to investigate the May 2010 "flotilla incident," when six ships sailing from Turkey to Gaza on an alleged humanitarian mission were boarded by Israeli commandos enforcing a naval blockade of Gaza. Nine passengers were killed (and several Israeli soldiers badly beaten) in the ensuing melee, sparking a crisis in Jerusalem's already frayed relations with Ankara.

Given the U.N.'s track record on Israel, one might have expected this latest report to be a reprise of Richard Goldstone's notorious report alleging Israeli war crimes during its 2009 war with Gaza (charges later retracted by Mr. Goldstone). Instead, the Palmer report offers a point-by-point rebuttal to some of the most preposterous accusations leveled against Israel.

One such accusation from the Turks is that Israel's naval blockade of Gaza is illegal because blockades can only be legally imposed on another state, and Israel has never recognized Palestine as a state. The Palmer report dismisses that legal legerdemain, noting that "Hamas is the de facto political and administrative authority in Gaza," that "it is Hamas that is firing projectiles into Israel or permitting others to do so," that "law does not operate in a political vacuum" and thus "Israel was entitled to take reasonable steps to prevent the influx of weapons into Gaza."

Glick - Ankara's chosen scapegoat

Caroline Glick
carolineglick.com
05 September '11



http://www.carolineglick.com/e/2011/09/turkeys-chosen-scapegoat.php

Monday morning Turkey took its anti-Israel campaign to a new level. Beyond downgrading diplomatic relations with Israel; beyond suspending military agreements; beyond threatening naval war; beyond threatening to foment an irredentist insurrection of Israeli Arabs; the Turks decided to terrorize Israeli tourists landing in Istanbul airport.

Forty Israeli passengers, mainly businessmen who had landed in Istanbul on a Turkish Airlines flight from Tel Aviv, were separated from the rest of the flight passengers. Their passports were confiscated.

They were placed in interrogation rooms and stripped down to their underwear. Their carry-on bags were checked. And then they were lined up against a wall, forbidden to sit down or use the washroom.

Passengers who contacted the Foreign Ministry said they felt frightened and intimidated.

The ordeal went on for 90 minutes, until Turkish authorities returned their Israeli passports and permitted them to pick up their suitcases and exit the airport.

What were the Turks trying to accomplish by terrifying the Israeli tourists? They didn't need to threaten trade ties. Their Foreign Minister Ahmet Davutoglu already took care of that over the weekend.

The victimized Israelis said the Turkish airport authorities wouldn't even answer their questions. Any time we asked them a question, the tourists said, the Turks ignored us.

It was as if they weren't even there.

And that's the thing of it. The Turks didn't harass the Israeli tourists in order to send a message to Israel. They have nothing more to say to us. We are non-entities to them. We're only good for attacking.

No, Israel wasn't the target audience the Turks were playing to on Monday. Their target audience was the Islamic world generally and the Arab world specifically. Turkey's influence in these arenas skyrocketed in January 2009 after Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan accused President Shimon Peres and Israel of mass murder as the leaders shared a stage at the Davos Conference.

Tobin - Turks Turned Their Backs on America Before Dumping Israel

Jonathan S. Tobin
Commentary/Contentions
04 September '11

http://www.commentarymagazine.com/2011/09/04/turkey-israel-erdogan-us/#more-766440

In the view of some critics of Israel, Turkey’s decision to downgrade its diplomatic ties with the Jewish state is more than just a setback. It is seen as further evidence of Israel’s intransigence as the Netanyahu government allowed its foolish pride to alienate an important ally and unnecessarily heighten the nation’s diplomatic isolation.

But this false narrative doesn’t just get the dispute between Israel and Turkey wrong. It is based on a misreading of the fundamental shift in Turkey’s foreign policy that predates the Gaza flotilla dustup that served as the spark for the current contretemps. It is important to remember that long before Turkey tried to break the blockade of Hamas-run Gaza, its Islamic government had not only distanced itself from Israel but had begun to turn its back on the United States.


No blame should attach to Netanyahu for Turkey’s decision to expel Israel’s ambassador and to reduce the level of its own representation in the Jewish state. The long negotiations between the two countries over the content of the United Nations report on the Mavi Marmara incident blew up because Turkey had no intention of accepting anything close to a compromise. Netanyahu was ready to express “regret” for the deaths of several Turkish nationals who were killed while resisting an Israeli boarding party. But as even the final UN report noted, Israel’s blockade of the terrorist state in Gaza was legal. The report also said the Israeli soldiers who landed on the ships were attacked by the Turks in an act of organized and violent resistance and had a right to defend themselves. That a UN report would fundamentally vindicate Israel’s position shows how unreasonable Turkey has been.

For Israel to go beyond an expression of regret to a full “apology” for its actions as the Turks demanded would have opened up the door to attempts to hold the Israeli soldiers in question accountable in international courts. It would also have compromised Israel’s right of self-defense against Hamas or any party, such as the Turks in the flotilla, seeking to re-supply the terrorists.

However, the problem here is not just that Israel was in the right, but the cooling off of relations with Turkey predated the argument over the flotilla. The once close ties between Israel and Turkey, and in particular, their militaries, had begun to fray ever since the latter’s government was taken over by Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan’s Islamic Justice and Development Party in 2003. Turkey’s tilt toward Hamas and away from Israel is an inevitable consequence of Ankara’s desire to become a leader in the Islamic world in the fashion of the Ottomans rather than to be an integral part of Europe and the West. No apology from Israel or diplomatic concessions made to the Palestinians can restore the former relationship.

The lack of perspective about Turkey’s diplomatic offensive against Israel is all the more egregious because it also ignores Erdoğan’s policy shift away from the United States. In 2003, Turkey’s decision not to allow coalition troops to use their territory in the effort to depose Saddam Hussein in Iraq not only was a blow to the U.S.-Turkey alliance but set in motion circumstances that ultimately helped create the insurgency. Since then, Turkey has consistently set itself apart from its NATO allies on a host of security issues. Erdoğan’s desire to strengthen Turkey’s trade ties with Iran has fatally undermined the sanctions the United States has sought to impose on the Islamist regime’s effort to gain nuclear capability.

Those who wish to blame Netanyahu for the loss of Israel’s Turkish alliance have short memories. Long before the Turks provoked and then dumped Israel in their pursuit of greater influence among Muslims, they did the same to the United States. Rather than wondering what Israel can do to abase itself in order to regain Turkey’s good will, the better question to ask is what actions the United States Congress and the Obama administration can now take to show their displeasure with Ankara.

If you enjoy "Love of the Land", please be a subscriber. Just put your email address in the "Subscribe" box on the upper right-hand corner of the page.
.

Monday, September 5, 2011

Divest This! - BDS – Beginning of the End?

Jon
Divest This!
05 September '11

http://www.divestthis.com/2011/09/bds-beginning-of-end.html

As I was planning to say before last week’s interruption, it may be getting to the point where we want to think about what a “final” defeat for BDS might look like.

After all, a “movement” that manages to turn the entire Australian political system and Noam Chomsky against them, a political project capable of creating 6000 Israel supporters in a single night (in Britain no less) must at some point come under the scrutiny of even the most fantasy-laden anti-Israel activists as something less than productive to their cause.

To understand whether BDS is on its way out, it is important to first remember what it is. Despite claims to be some sort of a “peace movement,” BDS is neither peaceful (being little more than a propaganda adjunct to more violent warriors who get to do the trigger pulling) nor, technically, a “movement.” Rather, BDS is simply a tactic that’s been used on and off for the last decade by the same anti-Israel crowd that has traveled under different names using different tactics.

Now this tactic has been successful in generating headlines and giving Israel dislikers a simple message to organize around and recruit new members. But outside such inside baseball, the tactic has proven to be a bust in its key mission of getting well known civic institutions to tie their name and reputation to the “Israel = Apartheid” message. In fact, given how successful anti-Israel forces have been in dragging international organizations (such as human rights NGOs and the United Nations) into their propaganda web, it’s a testament to the schools, churches, cities and other organizations that have resisted the BDS lure for close to a decade that they have kept themselves un-befouled by similar corruption.

Keep in mind that we have been exactly at this same point twice before. In 2004, advocates for divestment faced a serious credibility crisis after two years of zero success trying to get colleges and universities to divest from Israel. Had the Presbyterian Church not thrown them a lifeline in ‘04, they might not have lasted past that year and even church support simply put off the ultimate defeat of divestment in 2006 when the Presbyterians gave “the movement” the boot.

Benson - Palestinian Statehood: Fear and Loathing in Ramallah and the Diaspora

Pesach Benson
Honest Reporting/Backspin
04 September '11





As Mahmoud Abbas pushes forward with his statehood gambit in the UN, there’s a growing unease among Palestinians that the effort will ultimately be a big setback.

Commentaries by Khaled Abu Toameh and Mehdi Hasan reflect the anxiety that is prompting Abbas to deliver a speech in the coming days explaining his political strategy. Toameh is particularly harsh:

Abbas is so desperate that he is prepared to go to the UN even if such a move could turn out to be counterproductive for his people. At all costs, he wants to enjoy the glory of being the “first president of Palestine”

The LA Times traces the fear and loathing to a month-old legal opinion written by an Oxford wonk with serious credentials. among the Palestinians. Guy Goodwin-Gill was a member of the legal team that argued against the legality of Israel’s security fence in the International Criminal Court. (The ICJ ruled against Israel in 2004.)

Goodwin-Gill’s opinion raises issues with Palestinian statehood, and the status of the PLO as the sole representative of the Palestinian people:

(Read full "Palestinian Statehood: Fear and Loathing in Ramallah and the Diaspora")

If you enjoy "Love of the Land", please be a subscriber. Just put your email address in the "Subscribe" box on the upper right-hand corner of the page.
.

Fresnozionism - NIF leader: disappearance of Jewish state no tragedy

Fresnozionism.org
05 September '11

http://fresnozionism.org/2011/09/nif-leader-disappearance-of-jewish-state-no-tragedy/



This is stunning.

Actually, it’s completely expected, not surprising at all. It’s like your spouse admitting to having an affair. You knew it all along but hearing from her own lips is … stunning.

Last year, the US Embassy in Tel Aviv interviewed a number of people in connection with a law being considered by the Knesset to require transparency in non-governmental organization (NGO) funding.

It had become common knowledge that huge amounts of money from such sources as European governments and the New Israel Fund (NIF) in the US were flowing to ‘Israeli’ NGOs — primarily left-wing organizations — which were acting against the interests of the State of Israel. A particularly egregious example was the way a group of these NGOs provided almost all of the anti-IDF material in the UN’s vicious blood libel, the Goldstone Report.

Ambassador James B. Cunningham reported on the interviews in a cable sent to the State Department on February 25, 2010, now made public by Wikileaks. The cable includes an explanation by Dr. Gerald Steinberg of NGO Monitor (a source I’ve quoted often) of why the legislation, based on the US Foreign Agents Registration Act (FARA) is needed.

You should read that, but let’s cut to the chase. Ambassador Cunningham’s cable included this:

New Israel Fund (NIF) [former] Associate Director in Israel Hedva Radovanitz, who manages grants to 350 NGOs totaling about 18 million dollars per year, told PolOff [political officer] on February 23 that the campaign against the NGOs was due to the “disappearance of the political left wing” in Israel and the lack of domestic constituency for the NGOs. She noted that when she headed ACRI’s [Association for Civil Rights in Israel] Tel Aviv office, ACRI had 5,000 members, while today it has less than 800, and it was only able to muster about 5,000 people to its December human rights march by relying on the active staff of the 120 NGOs that participated. Radovanitz commented that the NIF was working behind the scenes through many NGOs to prevent the NGO legislation from passing in its current form. She commented that she believed that in 100 years Israel would be majority Arab and that the disappearance of a Jewish state would not be the tragedy that Israelis fear since it would become more democratic.

Could we roll the tape back, please:

She commented that she believed that in 100 years Israel would be majority Arab and that the disappearance of a Jewish state would not be the tragedy that Israelis fear since it would become more democratic.

I would like all of my friends here in America who contribute to the NIF because they would like Israel to become “more democratic” to please read that again, and think about it.

Meltzer - Déjà vu in Israel

Yoel Meltzer
yoelmeltzer.com
04 September '11

http://yoelmeltzer.com/deja-vu-in-israel/




Like many people who live in Israel, I have various thoughts concerning the ongoing social protests. While some of these were recorded in “Reflections on the Protests”, the one question that remains unanswered is “Who is providing the massive organizational and logistical support, as well as the enormous funding, for the ongoing protests throughout the country?” These things don’t just “happen” without lots and lots of help.

Moreover, the warm embrace of the protestors by the predominantly left-wing Israeli media, the same media which vilified many of the protestors of the Gaza Disengagement a few years back, makes the whole thing appear a bit suspicious. This does not mean to suggest that there isn’t a problem in Israel, since there is. However, the unanswered questions and the support of the media simply strengthen the feeling that there is more to this than meets the eye.

It appears that some of the details are finally coming to light. According to a lengthy investigative report from Kalman Libeskind, a well-known Israeli journalist who writes for the Maariv newspaper, the protest movements were planned back in March by democratic strategist Stanley Greenberg together with similar left-leaning Israeli counterparts in order to remove the Israeli right from power.

This group, the same bunch that helped bring Ehud Barak to power in place of Benjamin Netanyahu back in 1999, realized that on a platform of security, always the hottest election issue in Israel, the Israeli political left simply has no chance of replacing the right. Nearly twenty years of the Oslo process and the naïve attempts of land for peace have exposed the policies of the left as nothing less than disastrous.

Thus, another way was needed to replace the right in order to more easily advance the suicidal policies of the left. In such an environment, frustration throughout the country with the continually rising cost of living provided the way.

Hence the protest movement, according to Libeskind’s report, is merely a ploy to enable the creation of a new political party that will allegedly focus on social issues. Moreover, benefiting from the broad support for the protests, this new party will be positioned to take over the reigns of power. Once there, the real plan will be set in motion, namely to expedite the creation of a Palestinian state in Judea and Samaria.

Assuming that Libeskind is correct, the question is “Will Israeli’s be fooled again?” Back in 1999 the country bought into the “One Israel” campaign, a message that appeared to generate hope, and in doing so brought Ehud Barak to power. Barak in turn tried to quickly implement all the dreams of the left – a Palestinian state in 95% of Judea-Samaria-Gaza, the return of nearly the entire Golan Heights to Syria, the swift removal of Israeli troops from Southern Lebanon – and in doing so planted the seeds for the deadly second intifada and all the events since.

History is repeating itself. Let’s just hope that Israelis have learned a lesson.

If you enjoy "Love of the Land", please be a subscriber. Just put your email address in the "Subscribe" box on the upper right-hand corner of the page.
.

Fresnozionism - Norway: a ‘moral superpower’?

Norwegian fascist Vidkun
Quisling inspects Norwegian
Legion troops, in pre-
'moral superpower' days
Fresnozionism.org
04 September '11

http://fresnozionism.org/2011/09/norway-a-moral-superpower/


Norway, the American Ambassador wrote in a 2009 cable, wants to play a role in the Middle East ‘peace process’:

Norway’s desire to make a difference combined with the willingness to expend time and money has made it a mediator in conflicts as far a field as Sri Lanka, Colombia, Haiti, and Sudan. It has elevated peace and reconciliation studies in its universities and reorganized its Foreign Ministry to showcase its expertise in this area. It revels in its self-described role as the “moral superpower” and points to the Oslo Peace Accords as a defining national moment.

“Moral superpower.” What a concept!

But moral superiority begins at home. Does the name Jostein Gaarder ring a bell?

He is a Norwegian writer and intellectual, author of numerous books and winner of several prestigious Norwegian and international prizes. He is also known as an environmental and human-rights activist. In 2006, during the Second Lebanon war, he published a song of hatred for the Jewish state — and the Jewish people — in the Aftenposten, now the largest newspaper in Norway, entitled “God’s Chosen People.” It began as follows:

(Video) Elder - "Peace" - Palestinian style

elderofziyon2
Sep 4, 2011




Look at the map of "Palestine" in many Palestinian Arab organization logos. Not much room for Israel, is there?



Also from Elder of Ziyon: The attitudes of Palestinian Arabs towards peace are not quite how they are portrayed in the media. Do we really need another Arab state where people are bred to hate?

Watch: What would a Palestinian State mean?

If you enjoy "Love of the Land", please be a subscriber. Just put your email address in the "Subscribe" box on the upper right-hand corner of the page.
.


Rubin - Israel’s Strategic Situation: Plenty to Worry About But Little to Fear

Barry Rubin
The Rubin Report
05 September '11

http://rubinreports.blogspot.com/2011/09/israels-strategic-situation-plenty-to.html

Since much of what I write about regional politics seems pessimistic, I periodically remind people why I’m an optimist, at least when it comes to Israel.

Even today, Israel’s security situation is as good as or better than it has been since any time since the establishment of the state. The two main threats have always been either a potential attack by most or all Arab armies or a high level of successful cross-border terrorism.

At present, though, by Israeli standards, these two threats are relatively low. The immediate problem is rocket, missile, and mortar attacks from the Gaza Strip. The longer-term threat—that seems to be continually postponed--is an Iranian nuclear capability

On the level of threats from states, the problem is relatively minimal. The Saudis and Gulf Arabs, whose economic support would be vital in any confrontation, don’t want war with Israel. The same point applies to Jordan. Syria is militarily weaker than ever and entangled in a revolution whose effects will convulse the country for years whatever the outcome.

Muammar Qadhafi’s likely overthrow in Libya won’t bring a friendlier regime but will reduce the sponsorship of international terrorism arising from his personal ambitions. Similarly, Iraq has dropped out of the conflict and turned inward, while the Kurdish-ruled sector in the north is friendly toward Israel. A new addition to that short friendly list is the Republic of South Sudan.

What of Iran? The “Arab Spring” may be a victory for Sunni Muslim Islamism but for that reason is an Iranian defeat. Tehran’s ambition of being hegemonic in the Middle East is blocked since it can no longer hope to become leader over the majority Sunni Muslims. Its rival, the Muslim Brotherhood, is the single most powerful force in Egypt, has “stolen” Hamas from Iran, and may do the same with Syria.

Moreover, Iran is taking far longer to get nuclear weapons than expected due to technical and other problems. The regime also faces potential internal revolt. Of course, Iran is a legitimate Israeli concern but the threat today is far less than it was expected to be several years ago. The likelihood of Israel attacking Iran’s nuclear installation has also dropped sharply.

If the Lavi fighter jet project had not been canceled ...

Love of the Land
05 September '11

On August 30, 1987, a cabinet resolution passed by only one vote that canceled the first and thus far only attempt at producing an Israeli-made fighter jet, the Lavi.

"This Week in History: Israel’s fighter jet is cancelled" discusses the development, the hope, and ultimately, fate of the Lavi, which began with expectations of creating the world's most advanced fighter aircraft, yet under increasing American pressure, and budgetary doubts both in the Israeli government, as well as amongst some of the IDF General Staff, ultimately ended with the cancellation of this project. Michael Omer-Man in this article, takes the reader through the Lavi's history, the insecurity caused by the state of Israel's economy, but also, and probably most importantly, the American pressure to cancel, which would prevent competition with the American arms industry production and sale of the F-16. Read full article

Was this a wise decision, a good decision, something that ultimately benefited the State of Israel and it's citizens? Former DM Moshe Arens addressed this topic last year when the issue of purchasing the new American F-35 came to the forefront. His article is worth revisiting once again (see below), and deals with issues that go beyond the monetary, but instead involve perhaps more seriously, the issues of both sovereignty and security. While Michael Omer-Man closes his article with

"Additionally, continued US military aid and loan guarantees have enabled Israel to maintain the most advanced air force in the Middle East by buying US-manufactured jets and retrofitting them with Israeli technology, some of which was originally designed for the Lavi."

the retrofitting of the F-35s with Israeli technology has become a major point of contention as of last year, and should give us pause to reevaluate once again our dependence on other nations, even America, if we wish to preserve our ability to act, based on our national needs.

F-35 - Take it or leave it:
By Moshe Arens

Op Ed in Haaretz Published 03:29 27.07.10
www.haaretz.com/print-edition/opinion/f-35-take-it-or-leave-it-1.304297

Who would have believed it? Some years ago Israel was developing the world's most advanced fighter aircraft, the Lavi, while the Western world's aircraft manufacturers were beating their way to our door, eager to participate in the Lavi project, or trying to sell their competing plane to the Israel Air Force. And now Israel goes hat in hand pleading for a chance to be allowed to acquire the F-35 aircraft, at a price tag of $150 million each. But it's not only the astronomical price. Israel is told that the F-35 must be taken as is - no changes or modifications to suit Israel's specific needs, and absolutely no Israeli systems included. Take it or leave it.

Just imagine Israel's position today had the Lavi project not been canceled. The IAF would be operating the world's most advanced fighter, upgraded over the years to incorporate operational experience and newer technology. Much of Israel's industry would have moved a great step ahead, Israel Aerospace Industries would have become a leading developer of fighter aircraft, and most importantly, a number of options would be open to the IAF in choosing its next fighter.

Sunday, September 4, 2011

Palmer, Goldstone, and the Palestinian statehood gambit

Love of the Land
04 September '11





Jennifer Rubin, writing in her Washington Post column today, covers considerable ground in her review of the U.N.'s Palmer Report. She notes, that it's conclusions, when one considers Israel's normal treatment at the hands of the U.N., is virtually a model of fairness and balance.

Having touched on all parties concerned, Ms. Rubin raises two points towards the end of her column, that address and go beyond the specific details of what occurred on the Mavi Marmara. First, that the commission concluded that Israel’s naval blockade of Gaza is both legal and appropriate, speaks to the recognition of a state of belligerency, completely absent from the heavily criticized Goldstone Report, and secondly that this state of belligerancy raises a powerful argument against granting the Palestinians their request for a declaration of statehood.

Jennifer Rubin:

Consider the report’s acknowledgment of the threat to Israel posed by Hamas terrorists:

The United Nations Charter, Article 2 (4) prohibits the use of force generally, subject to an exception under Article 51 of the Charter for the right of a nation to engage in self-defense. Israel has faced and continues to face a real threat to its security from militant groups in Gaza. Rockets, missiles and mortar bombs have been launched from Gaza toward Israel since 2001. More than 5,000 were fired between 2005 and January 2009, when the naval blockade was imposed. Hundreds of thousands of Israeli civilians live in the range of these attacks. As their effectiveness has increased,some rockets are now capable of reaching Tel Aviv. Since 2001 such attacks have caused more than 25 deaths and hundreds of injuries. The enormity of the psychological toll on the affected population cannot be underestimated. In addition, there have been substantial material losses. The purpose of these acts of violence, which have been repeatedly condemned by the international community, has been to do damage to the population of Israel. It seems obvious enough that stopping these violent acts was a necessary step for Israel to take in order to protect its people and to defend itself.

The report goes on to note:

Pollard - A Proms protest with a whiff of Weimar about it

Stephen Pollard
The Telegraph
04 September '11

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/culture/music/proms/8737692/A-Proms-protest-with-a-whiff-of-Weimar-about-it.html

The demonstration at the Israeli Philharmonic Orchestra BBC Proms concert was against Jews, not the Israeli state.

Until Thursday night, nothing in the history of Proms broadcasts had forced a concert off air. Certainly not the Soviet invasion of Czechoslovakia in 1968. On the very night the tanks moved into Prague, the great Russian cellist Mstislav Rostropovich was at the Proms with the USSR Symphony Orchestra. And he was performing, with intense poignancy, the Czech composer Dvorak’s cello concerto. I have a cherished recording of the concert. The audience was rapt and not a word was uttered.

When Chinese performers grace the Proms with their presence, there is not a word of protest about their government’s abuses of human rights. Nor should there be. They are musicians, not politicians.

But when the Israel Philharmonic played on Thursday evening, a band of around 30 thugs – none was wearing jackboots, but they should have been – launched into chanting and mock singing, disrupting the concert to such an extent that BBC Radio 3 decided it could not go on with the broadcast.

The corporation has come under attack for pulling the plug. Louise Mensch, the Conservative MP, called it a “disgraceful” decision. But I sympathise with the BBC. Why should a bunch of hooligans be given free rein on the airwaves to have their hooliganism validated with a broadcast? The real story isn’t the broadcast, but the behaviour of the anti-Zionists, which has opened many people’s eyes to their real agenda, and what really drives them.

As the IPO began Webern’s Passacaglia, a dozen people unfurled a banner reading “Free Palestine” and started to sing about “Israeli apartheid” and “violations of international law and human rights”. As the orchestra played over the disruption, the hooligans were removed by security guards. Then, as Gil Shaham, an Israeli violinist, prepared to play an encore after the Bruch violin concerto, another group began shouting and started to scuffle with audience members.

You can see videos of it on YouTube. They will remind you of something. It is inescapable. There is a chilling air to the so-called protests: an air of Weimar Germany, and the way Nazi party members broke up meetings.

(Uploaded by britishisraelc on Sep 1, 2011: The Audience at the Royal Albert Hall 
express their disgust as anti-Israel yobs disrupt Prom 62 featuring the Israel Philharmonic Orchestra. Yosef)


It shouldn’t need saying that protesting against the actions of the Israeli government is not the same as being anti-Semitic. Clearly not: this month, 250,000 Israelis joined rallies against their government’s economic policies. They could hardly be driven by anti-Semitism.