Saturday, November 18, 2017

Cleaning-up and sewing-up eastern Jerusalem - by David M. Weinberg

...The application of de facto sovereignty and governance on the ground is the core of political action that can keep Jerusalem whole. The struggle for sovereignty in eastern Jerusalem has transitioned from ‘Jerusalem on High’ – meaning, high-powered political summits in Oslo and Annapolis, to ‘Jerusalem of Below’ – meaning, the decent conduct of daily life in the city for Arab and Jewish residents alike.

David M. Weinberg..
A Citadel Defending Jerusalem..
16 November '17..

This week, Jerusalem municipal officials and workers swept overnight into A-Tur on the Mount of Olives to clean up the neighborhood.

Under police protection, they hauled away abandoned vehicles, piles of garbage, and rubble from ruined buildings. They took down dangerously placed signs and illegal sheds. They erased graffiti, fixed broken street lights, and painted road safety markings. They enforced business codes by confiscating merchandise placed in public areas without permits, checked for violations of safety rules, issued fines for illegally commandeered parking spaces, and more.

The police also combed through the neighborhood with lists in hand to confirm that people under house arrest were really at home. They found an illegally held M1 rifle, and arrested 20 Arab residents of east Jerusalem suspected of throwing rocks and firebombs at civilians and police.

A similar “sweep and clean” overnight campaign in Isawiyah, conducted last month by tax and building code officials, bailiffs and police, culminated in 51 arrests.

“The campaign is designed to firmly handle anybody involved in criminal offenses, [violations of] public order and terrorism, while at the same time improving the lives of the regular, law-abiding residents of the neighborhood by arresting people who violate public order and break the law,” the police said in a statement.

At a conference on the “Challenges of United Jerusalem” conducted by the new Jerusalem Institute for Strategic Studies, Jerusalem District police commander Maj. Gen. Yoram Halevy said these operations are meant to create balance.

“We want to show the residents of eastern Jerusalem that those who’ve done wrong will be treated as such and those who’ve done good will be rewarded,” he said. He said this was part of the implementation of a new strategy by the Jerusalem District Police to shift from only “chasing the bad guys” to also “nurturing the good guys,” so that the latter “can help the police help them.”

It is quite clear to me that there is more to this strategy than just “nurturing the good guys.” The enforcement operations are clearly part of a broader plan to ensure effective and equitable Israeli rule over a united Jerusalem. They aim to push back against proposals for cutting Arab neighborhoods out of the Jerusalem municipality or for handing them over to the Palestinian Authority.

Jerusalem Mayor Nir Barkat admitted as much at the JISS conference. “There is no municipal or political authority that can administer Jerusalem and service its residents, Arab and Jewish, better than the Municipality of Jerusalem,” he said. “I am committed to reducing the disparities and improving the level of services and infrastructure in Arab neighborhoods. We are investing more than NIS 50 million this year in the eastern parts of the city with an emphasis on roads, and will be investing NIS 500 million in classrooms over the coming decade.”

Barkat’s adviser on Arab and Christian affairs, Dr. David Koren, laid out the broader philosophy for Barkat’s approach in a detailed talk and a 6,000-word article. He says that governance and sovereign rule in eastern Jerusalem requires a quantum leap in the level of services provided by Israel, alongside effective community policing efforts.

“The struggle for sovereignty in Jerusalem has transitioned from ‘Jerusalem on High,’ meaning high-powered political summits in Oslo and Annapolis, to ‘Jerusalem of Below,’ meaning the conduct of daily life in the city,” Koren writes.

“The real limits to control and sovereignty in Jerusalem are not determined in clandestine talks between unnamed high-ranking officials, but rather by demarcating the area of ​​activity of the municipal street cleaner, the youth counselor at the local community center, the building inspector, the road engineer, the policeman and the social worker, who provide services for the residents and are clearly identified with Israeli institutions.”

Koren says eastern Jerusalem residents possess an intense desire for “permanence” and a clear resolution of their affiliation, whether to Israel or to the PA. Broad sectors of the Palestinian public hold a pragmatic attitude about Israeli authorities, he says, and they see Israel as the only possible source for solving their problems and turning their lives around. But there is a struggle between the PA and Israel for control of eastern Jerusalem, and it is being conducted by proxy, through the local residents, through their education and their pocketbooks. Koren says that whoever services eastern Jerusalem better will win.

We see a clear example of this in the area of education, where a struggle is taking place between parents’ committees in eastern Jerusalem: Some support the introduction of the Israeli curriculum into schools so as to broaden their children's educational and professional horizons, while those affiliated with the PA wish to preserve the Palestinian curriculum due to its national characteristics.

Barkat seems to be making progress in this regard. The number of eastern Jerusalem students who opted for the Israeli matriculation curriculum jumped by 20% this year, and over the past seven years has risen from 300 to 5,800 students.

Similarly, Palestinian youths in east Jerualem are torn between a growing number of colleges providing Hebrew classes with advanced professional training, and Fatah sports and cultural clubs with new budgets from the PA or Islamic outreach centers sponsored by Turkey, where they are taught “struggle.”

Another sovereign act of the first order is in the area of ​​planning and building. The municipality has just approved a master plan for home building in Sur Baher and Umm Tuba. Right-wing elements in the city opposed the plan, but Barkat and Koren argue that such advances for the benefit of eastern Jerusalem Arab residents is exactly what will keep Jerusalem whole and under Israeli sovereignty.

Along the same lines, the Israel Police is advancing a new security concept for enhanced police presence in eastern Jerusalem, through five integrated policing centers that provide civilian community services to Arab neighborhoods.

At the same time, Barkat and Halevy don’t mind admitting that when necessary, they have and will use tax collectors and building inspectors to “punish” bad behavior.

During the riots last summer in Jerusalem, which were led by residents from some particularly nasty clans in Issawiyah and Jabel Mukaber, the city blocked the exits from those neighborhoods and sent in inspectors (accompanied by police) who fined and penalized for every possible municipal infraction. When multiple families in a clan are hit hard for back taxes and utility bills, as well as for social security fraud, the neighborhood suddenly goes quiet and the disturbances peter out.

In short, the application of de facto sovereignty and governance on the ground is the core of political action that can keep Jerusalem whole.

David M. Weinberg ( is vice president of the Jerusalem Institute for Strategic Studies.

Updates throughout the day at If you enjoy "Love of the Land", please be a subscriber. Just put your email address in the "Subscribe" box on the upper right-hand corner of the page.Twitter updates at LoveoftheLand as well as our Love of the Land page at Facebook which has additional pieces of interest besides that which is posted on the blog. Also check-out This Ongoing War by Frimet and Arnold Roth. An excellent blog, very important work. 

No comments:

Post a Comment